Peanut Butter Meringue Pie from The Ranch Table

840 comments
Peanut Butter Pie in a ceramic pie plate on a marble countertop

I met Elizabeth Poett in Waco, TX after we both started filming our shows for The Magnolia Network. Elizabeth is the rare combination of movie star glamour and a down-to-earth rancher. Those things seem an impossible mix and yet, Elizabeth pulls it off with rugged elegance. She has a passion for her traditions, her land, and her family, which makes her so relatable.

[GIVEAWAY! Scroll to the bottom to find out how you can win a copy of Elizabeth Poett’s new cookbook!]

Her new cookbook tells the story of her picture book ranch, filled with cattle, honey bees, lavender fields, and views one could never get tired of. Most importantly it is where her family has lived for seven generations.

I am decidedly a city dweller but I am so captivated and curious about her bucolic world. If you’ve seen her show, Ranch to Table, you’ve probably felt the same pull to ranch life. You can get her recipes and stories in her new book, The Ranch Table, which includes this family-favorite peanut butter meringue pie. Be sure to check out Elizabeth’s show! Season 4 just launched on Magnolia Network.

Peanut Butter Pie in a ceramic pie plate on a marble countertop

GIVEAWAY! Want to win a copy of this gorgeous cookbook? Leave a comment and tell me your favorite pie or your favorite peanut butter dessert recipe! USA addresses only. Must be 18 years of age or older to enter. Giveaway closes Friday, Oct. 13, 2023 at 5 p.m. CST. One winner will be contacted via email. If we do not hear back from the winner within 48 hours, we will select and notify a new winner.

840 Comments

  1. Juanita Jungck

    I have a few faves, but there’s something about coconut cream that melts my heart!

  2. Kelly Julian

    Wild Black Raspberry Pie is my all time favorite! We discovered wild, black, raspberries on the side of our yard and picked them and made a pie, it was the most wonderful pie I have ever had!

  3. I love my moms apple pie..She has reached an age where she can no longer make it so we are doing it for her but it still doesn’t taste like hers

  4. Beckie Carbaugh

    My favorite pie is pumpkin pie made with fresh pumpkin.

  5. Strawberry Rhubarb Pie warmed and served with vanilla ice cream!

  6. Annette Amir

    I love making a quick no-bake peanut butter “Reese’s type of dessert, with melted chocolate on top!! So delicious!!

  7. My pumpkin pie!!
    Food Charlatan’s peanut butter cookie recipe and chocolate covered peanut balls.

  8. How am I supposed to pick just one favorite?!?! That’s nearly impossible! I’d say my top favorite pie would have to be either a cherry or a peach pie with a crisp/crumble topping. My favorite peanut butter dessert is definitely a classic chewy peanut butter cookie. So yummy!!

  9. dorothy smith

    My favorite dessert of all time is a good old custard pie that my Mom got out of an old cookbook from the 1950’s when I was a little girl. The cookbook no longer has a cover and I keep it in a plastic bag to protect it when I’m not using it. The pie is pure creamy indulgence.It leaves that creamy sweet film in your mouth when you eat it like creme brulee’ does. There is nothing better in the world.

  10. Made from scratch coconut cream pie.

  11. My mom makes a creamy peach pie from her best friend’s recipe…I love it! I use Alice Medrich’s peanut butter cookie recipe and put dark chocolate kisses on top for peanut blossom cookies…

  12. My favorite is an Apple Pie. I have a recipe from a Jiff peanut butter article. It’s a PB&J cookie. I took them to a cookie swap and they’re a hit.

  13. My favorite is a good ole buttery crusted Apple Pie. I have a recipe from a Jiff peanut butter article. It’s a PB&J cookie. I took them to a cookie swap and they’re a hit.

  14. Lemon meringue pie and cherry have been my favorites from as long as I can remember! Thanks for the opportunity to enter!

  15. Gail Berger

    Call me old fashioned, but now that I have the lattice top technique down pat (thanks to Zoe), my favorite, and my family’s favorite is Apple Pie!!
    This is the season too!

  16. Suzy Wintjen

    Chocolate cupcakes with peanut butter frosting!

  17. Cognac Coconut cream pie or Mexican Chocolate Pie!

  18. Tami Barker-Young

    I honestly cannot think of any pie I don’t like; however, I do love lemon meringue! The tartness of the lemon filling contrasted with the sweet, puffy meringue is a sure winner in pie world!

  19. I Love Peanut Butter pie! I will be giving this one a try! I Love strawberry and Rhubarb pie too!
    Thank you for the Giveaway.
    Hugs,
    Teresa

  20. My family is big on pies; birthday desserts are almost always some type of pie. My father’s favorite pie is “fruit with a crust around it”, especially if it has a crumb topping.
    My personal favorite is ginger custard pie with lots of candied ginger mixed in.

  21. Lisa Gilbert

    My favorite pie is key lime cheese cake pie!

  22. My favorite pie is Peach Crumb!

  23. I love rhubarb pie – and most other pies too. My favorite peanut butter dessert is Smitten Kitchen’s chocolate peanut butter cake.

  24. Pamela Serafin

    Hi. Pam here. My favorite pie is my Mom’s lemon meringue. But I will have to try this peanut butter meringue. It looks yummy.

  25. Auntiepatch

    I lost my favorite peanut butter pie recipe during a move 45 years ago! It had a pretzel crust and everybody loved it!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*