I met Elizabeth Poett in Waco, TX after we both started filming our shows for The Magnolia Network. Elizabeth is the rare combination of movie star glamour and a down-to-earth rancher. Those things seem an impossible mix and yet, Elizabeth pulls it off with rugged elegance. She has a passion for her traditions, her land, and her family, which makes her so relatable.
[GIVEAWAY! Scroll to the bottom to find out how you can win a copy of Elizabeth Poett’s new cookbook!]
Her new cookbook tells the story of her picture book ranch, filled with cattle, honey bees, lavender fields, and views one could never get tired of. Most importantly it is where her family has lived for seven generations.
I am decidedly a city dweller but I am so captivated and curious about her bucolic world. If you’ve seen her show, Ranch to Table, you’ve probably felt the same pull to ranch life. You can get her recipes and stories in her new book, The Ranch Table, which includes this family-favorite peanut butter meringue pie. Be sure to check out Elizabeth’s show! Season 4 just launched on Magnolia Network.
GIVEAWAY! Want to win a copy of this gorgeous cookbook? Leave a comment and tell me your favorite pie or your favorite peanut butter dessert recipe! USA addresses only. Must be 18 years of age or older to enter. Giveaway closes Friday, Oct. 13, 2023 at 5 p.m. CST. One winner will be contacted via email. If we do not hear back from the winner within 48 hours, we will select and notify a new winner.
My favorite pie is Key Lime Pie. My favorite Peanut Butter recipe is Peanut Butter/Choclate Eggs
My favorite pie is a black-bottom roasted strawberry pie with chocolate meringue!
My goodness ~ this sounds amazing!!!
Classic Pecan Pie! I have a scar on my wrist where as a toddler I tried to reach a pecan pie right out of the oven. I learned the meaning of the word “hot” but still love the pie as much today!
Pecan pie is the best! I cannot imagine a world without nuts, and having them in a sumptuous pie is a treat in every way.
Pumpkin Pie of course,,, Fav Peanut butter are chocolate chip peanut butter cookies
I love coconut cream but that peanut butter pie looks awfully good!!! Would love to win this cookbook!
My favorite pie is a warm rhubarb pie with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. Yum!
My favorite pie is apple with apple crisp ice cream that our local creamery makes.
my favorite pie is coconut cream. I’ve watched her show, pretty good.
Fav pie is Boston Cream Pie…and fav PB dessert is Peanut Butter & Jelly bars
I am a big time pie lover! My new favorite is a pineapple cream pie with meringue topping and macadamia graham crust. I fell in love with it in Hawaii (stationed here for a spell). But I would swoon for pretty much any pie with a delicious flaky crust and oozing berry juice… or a chocolate and peanut butter cream pie that is meltingly delicious on the palate!
Ohh I love a banana cream pie or anything chocolate like a chocolate silk pie!
Strawberry rhubarb
Cool and refreshing Raspberry Cream Pie made with homegrown, perfectly ripe raspberries.
In the fall, I love apple pie with a pecan crumble topping and in the summer, a tart lemon icebox pie. I love simple peanut butter cookies with a Hersey’s kiss melted on top.
I love apricot pie, pecan pie, peach pie
I’ll never turn down a blueberry pie, but peanut butter in any form wins my tastebuds over all!
A peanut butter mountain, peanut butter pie, peanut butter cookies dipped in white chocolate, etc…
Let’s bring on the meringue
Definitely pumpkin!
Toffee Trifle Tiramisu
I love cherry pie!
Apple has always been my favorite ❤️
updated email address
Favorite pie: berry. favorite peanut butter recipe: peanut butter cookies
Pecan pie. I thought my mom makes the best pecan pies, but now my son is making them and I think they are better.
Cherry pie vs. French apple pie (or whatever it’s called; you know the one with apples topped with a cinnamon crumble…mmmm).
My favorite pie is chocolate creme, so a peanut butter creme pie or the combination of the two sounds heavenly!
A good old fashion peanut butter cookie. I swap out the short name for olive oil in mind. They are delicious.
I like Dulce de Leche Apple Pie
Joanna Gaines chocolate and peanut butter briwnies
My favorite is chocolate meringue pie!
Pecan pie is my fave!
Pie– any pie-all pie. What’s not to love!
Banana cream pie!
My favorite pie is pecan pie.
Hands down my favorite pie is Zucchini “mock apple” pie. It tastes just as good plus I love seeing people’s reaction when tell them it’s zucchini!
I love huckleberry pie! But the recipe that I’m hunting for is my dad’s childhood favorite: sour cream and raisin….
One of my favorites is chocolate peanut butter pie! The best! It’s like eating a creamy Reeses!
my favorite pie is peach.
My fAvorite pie is coconut custard. I never know whether to eat a slice or just eat the whole inside out. Do I start with a sliver and just keep adding more slivers. That way you really don’t feel guilty
Love your show & Ranch to Table & learn so much from you guys. I was born in Nova Scotia and my favorite pie as a child was Boysenberry 🙂 Now, many years later, and in Texas with six grandchildren is any pie, cobble, tart or peanut butter chocolate chip cookie I can make with them
100% peanut butter pie! Although I did have a blueberry pie this year that was out of this world. Most of the blueberries were not cooked. Only a small portion had been cooked on the stovetop and then mixed with the uncooked blueberries and put in a graham cracker crust shell. Delicious. The pie came from a restaraunt in New Jersey: Steve and Cookies.
My hands down favorite pie is Sour Cherry! One bite and I am transported back to my childhood years of picking cherries with my siblings and the pie that always followed from our mother. A sour cherry lattice crust pie graces our table each Thanksgiving as a reminder of the good times both past and present.
My current favorite pie is….drumroll, please….King Fluffernutter Pie. Peanut butter. Bananas. Bacon. Marshmallow creme. It’s a ridiculously beautiful ode to Elvis.
The recipe is in _New Pie_ by the brilliant Chris Taylor and Paul Arguin pie-making duo.
They inspired me to learn pie making during the COVID shutdown — my license plate now says “MKE PIE.” MKE = Make or Milwaukee. (I live just outside of the great city of Milwaukee.) I am grateful for their inspiration..
I love pie, almost all pies, maybe apple pie a bit more than cherry pie, and maybe lemon pie more than pumpkin pie. If I am the piemaker, I like rustic pies.
I love your recipes!
I have a great recipe that is made like a dessert pizza! Sugar cookie crust and peanut butter and cream cheese combined as the next layer, topped with sliced apples, caramel drizzle and chopped peanuts! soooo good! I love Elizabeth also! She seems so down-to-Earth and I love that table she uses as an island in her kitchen!
Wild Black Raspberry is my ALL time FAVORITE pie! We found wild Black Raspberries in our yard and picked them to make a pie..Oh my goodness, BEST pie I’ve ever had!
Sour cherry pie is my favorite pie. Alas, I haven’t found sour cherries since I moved to NC 10 years ago. My second favorite is strawberry rhubarb pie.
Elizabeth’s peanut butter pie and coconut cream pie are. the best!!!!
French silk pie is my favorite
Pies? Favorite is Pecan…but then there’s blueberry….and Sour Cream Cherry. (don’t forget the savory pot pies!)
Decisions, decisions, pies are great.
Sweet potato pie is by far my favorite!
I have a few faves, but there’s something about coconut cream that melts my heart!
Wild Black Raspberry Pie is my all time favorite! We discovered wild, black, raspberries on the side of our yard and picked them and made a pie, it was the most wonderful pie I have ever had!
I love my moms apple pie..She has reached an age where she can no longer make it so we are doing it for her but it still doesn’t taste like hers
My favorite pie is pumpkin pie made with fresh pumpkin.
Strawberry Rhubarb Pie warmed and served with vanilla ice cream!
I love making a quick no-bake peanut butter “Reese’s type of dessert, with melted chocolate on top!! So delicious!!
My pumpkin pie!!
Food Charlatan’s peanut butter cookie recipe and chocolate covered peanut balls.
How am I supposed to pick just one favorite?!?! That’s nearly impossible! I’d say my top favorite pie would have to be either a cherry or a peach pie with a crisp/crumble topping. My favorite peanut butter dessert is definitely a classic chewy peanut butter cookie. So yummy!!
My favorite dessert of all time is a good old custard pie that my Mom got out of an old cookbook from the 1950’s when I was a little girl. The cookbook no longer has a cover and I keep it in a plastic bag to protect it when I’m not using it. The pie is pure creamy indulgence.It leaves that creamy sweet film in your mouth when you eat it like creme brulee’ does. There is nothing better in the world.
Made from scratch coconut cream pie.
My mom makes a creamy peach pie from her best friend’s recipe…I love it! I use Alice Medrich’s peanut butter cookie recipe and put dark chocolate kisses on top for peanut blossom cookies…
My favorite is an Apple Pie. I have a recipe from a Jiff peanut butter article. It’s a PB&J cookie. I took them to a cookie swap and they’re a hit.
My favorite is a good ole buttery crusted Apple Pie. I have a recipe from a Jiff peanut butter article. It’s a PB&J cookie. I took them to a cookie swap and they’re a hit.
Lemon meringue pie and cherry have been my favorites from as long as I can remember! Thanks for the opportunity to enter!
Call me old fashioned, but now that I have the lattice top technique down pat (thanks to Zoe), my favorite, and my family’s favorite is Apple Pie!!
This is the season too!
Chocolate cupcakes with peanut butter frosting!
Cognac Coconut cream pie or Mexican Chocolate Pie!
I honestly cannot think of any pie I don’t like; however, I do love lemon meringue! The tartness of the lemon filling contrasted with the sweet, puffy meringue is a sure winner in pie world!
I Love Peanut Butter pie! I will be giving this one a try! I Love strawberry and Rhubarb pie too!
Thank you for the Giveaway.
Hugs,
Teresa
My family is big on pies; birthday desserts are almost always some type of pie. My father’s favorite pie is “fruit with a crust around it”, especially if it has a crumb topping.
My personal favorite is ginger custard pie with lots of candied ginger mixed in.
My favorite pie is key lime cheese cake pie!
My favorite pie is Peach Crumb!
I love rhubarb pie – and most other pies too. My favorite peanut butter dessert is Smitten Kitchen’s chocolate peanut butter cake.
Hi. Pam here. My favorite pie is my Mom’s lemon meringue. But I will have to try this peanut butter meringue. It looks yummy.
I lost my favorite peanut butter pie recipe during a move 45 years ago! It had a pretzel crust and everybody loved it!
My favorite pie is Chocolate Pie!
Apple pie!!
My favorite pie is made scratch Coconut Cream Pie.
My favorite pie is strawberry rhubarb!
In my family, we have a recipe we called pb heaven. It’s pretty much a 7 layer bar but everything is peanut – the cookies in the crust, chip, pb cups, butterfinger. It’s so delicious.
I love all pie!! But my favors are lemon meringue and apple crumb! Oooh it’s so good!!
I love a good, old fashioned chocolate parfait with a whipped peanut butter cream!
I love French Silk pie although peanut butter pie is a very close second! This one looks delicious and I can’t wait to try making it!
Huckleberry Pie! My old home had many wild huckleberry bushes and I loved to pick them warm and fresh, and make a delicious pie. They are so tiny that perhaps the work in picking makes the pie even more coveted to me.
Favorite pie is strawberry rhubarb and my favorite peanut butter dessert are peanut butter pretzel chocolate bars!
All pies are delicious! My favorite is gooseberry. If you find it out you know it is homemade as few people make this pie anymore
My favorite pie is apple mincemeat, with a hot cup of coffee!
Dutch apple pie is my favorite
Never made a meringue on a pie would love to try it hopefully a recipe in this book
I love blueberry pie! my favorite book growing up was Blueberries for Sal every time I eat blueberry pie I remember that book!
I love banana cream pie
My favorite pie is chocolate cream pie!
I am from the Buckeye state: OHIO . What we love in Ohio is Buckeye’s Made with peanut butter and chocolate. They are soooo good. Can you make them???
I would have a hard time choosing between a chocolate peanut butter marble cheesecake and a peanut butter banana cheesecake.
My favorite pie is a buttermilk pie and I don’t know why I think I can only have it during the holidays haha!
My favorite pie: apple! But really, all fruit pie!
Apple pie and buckeyes!
So funny this came up! I am not much of a pie person, BUT I just recently made a peanut butter custard pie from Vintage Bakes by Jessie Sheehan, and while I had some troubles with the recipe (including burning my palm when the custard spattered!), I will DEFINITELY be making it again as both my kids declared it a contender for a birthday dessert. So, it’s for sure my favorite peanut butter dessert now!
Apple Pie with a cheddar cheese crust..my mother was born in Fall River,MA. and loves this combo.
Sorry, my email was typed incorrectly!
My favorite pie hands down is Dutch Apple Pie; however I do love a good Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Muffin every now & then!
I find myself longing for my Grandmother’s plain and simple custard pie. There is no written recipe from her and my attempts have not measured up to the creaminess of her custard and flaky crust. Old family recipes are treasures that leave lasting memories.
I love a delicious chocolate cream pie!
Bourbon chocolate pecan pie!! Love me some pie in the South;)
Peach pie! But cherry pie and lemon meringue are a very close second
Dark chocolate brownie pie with fresh whipped cream!
My favorite pie is blueberry pie!! I will freeze blueberries just to make it on a really cold Winter day.
Lemon Meringue Pie is my favorite!
I love a fresh blueberry or apple pie!
My favorite peanut butter pie is Mrs Salter’s from Paula Dean. I do add chocolate ganache to mine.
I love creamy pies, pies with nuts and fresh fruit pies.
My favorite pie is rhubarb custard pie. I always think of my dad when I make it as it was his favorite pie too.
Oooo I love creme de menthe pie
My favorite pie is chocolate chip peanut butter pie.
Apple custard pie is one of my favorites!
I would say that there is more than one type of pie to love each season. But to narrow it down, I love to make and share blueberry pie.
1) Rhubarb
and
2) Pecan pie
I don’t like to discriminate against any pie… But my favorite is pumpkin…365 days a year!
Chocolate Cream Pie!
Chocolate pecan pie! No calories, right?
How does one pick a favorite pie? I love fruit pies and I love looking forward to the one that celebrates the current season or harvest. From strawberry rhubarb to blueberry to apple to pumpkin, they are all delicious, especially at the peak of their season. It’s like eating your way thru the weeks and months of spring, summer and fall!
My daughter (Kenyon ‘25) and my fav is lemon meringue pie!
Rather than going on about my fav pie (Tart Cherry) I will name my husband’s favorite, Mincemeat! My mother shared this same love. It was an immediate mother-in-love and son-in-love match made in heaven. I usually only make it twice a year, for Christmas and birthdays. I add sliced cinnamon apples on the bottom and then spread the mincemeat between top and bottom of homemade crusts. After it’s done, serve with Vanilla ice cream. Mmm good
Pie! Glorious pie! Definitely something to love and oh how hard to choose a favorite! One of my faves is a bit out of the ordinary – blueberry-gooseberry pie combined to make a delicious pie, if you grow gooseberries it is the best tasting. Try wild blueberries if you have a chance to walk in the woods. It will take a lot of berries but worth it. Brings back memories of searching for blueberries in northern Minnesota with my grandma who so enjoyed baking and cooking~
Lemon Meringue Pie is my favorite
That’s a tough one! If I could only have one it would be Aussie Key Lime Pie, it has the most delish chewy oatmeal cookie crust which is the perfect compliment to the tart lime filling.
My favorite peanut butter dessert is a good old fashioned chewy peanut butter cookie.
Salted caramel pecan pie!
My favorite pie is Sweet potato pecan!
Pumpkin cream pie with a gingersnap crust
My favorite ie is homemade pumpkin pie. It is best with fresh pumpkin puree and homemade crust with a do dollop of whip cream. This one pie holds so many memories.
I love key lime pie and pecan pie…both were made by mother-in-law. Her crusts were one of the best!!
My favorite pie to make for family and friends is huckleberry cream cheese pie using those delicious Idaho huckleberries. A gem from the Gem State.
My favorite pie is cherry. But a close second is a pumpkin cheesecake swirl pie.
Key Lime
My favorite is Olallieberry pie.
My mom’s homemade chocolate pie is the absolute best thing to ever hit your tongue!! I’m soooo glad I got her recipe!! My second choice woukd be a chess pie. mmmmm now I’m hungry!!
Coconut ice cream with peanut butter swirl, chocolate chips and puffed rice. For pie, apple is always my favorite
I’ve always been a fan of sweet potato or pumpkin pie but this pb meringue looks delish! I love meringue!
It’s a toss up, Coconut Cream pie / Key Lime Pie!!
homemade pecan pie.
My favorite pie is apple pie.
Love to make triple berry pie!
My favorite pie is pecan pie
Hi, Zoe! I really love toasted coconut pie! Simple and delicious! I may experiment making it Keto friendly!
My favorite pie is a buttermilk pie or pecan pie.
My favorite pie is Key Lime
Traditional apple pie is my favorite
My favorite pie to make is a simple chocolate pie that my Mother-in-law made for my husband every Christmas. I’ve now passed it on to my daughters. I love a good apple pie.
My favorite pie is traditional apple pie. Second, cherry pie.
I like this deep dish apple tart pie. I like so many though it’s hard to have a favorite. My fav lately has been lemon meringue. Whenever I go out to visit family in Utah, if I happen to be in the area of Bicknell Utah, I have to stop at this place called the Sunglow restaurant and they sell this sampler that has 4 small slices of pie: pickle, buttermilk, oatmeal, and pinto bean…surprisingly they are really good too!
I love a good chocolate cream pie with meringue!
My favorite is fresh Michigan Red Haven peach pie. Double crust of course with a nice sprinkle of sugar on top.
My favorite pie is coconut cream!
My favorite pie is my Mema’s apple pie made with her mother’s crust recipe. So delicious and nostalgic!
My favorite pie is Salted Carmel Banana Cream. Everything is made from scratch. It is yummy!
My favorite would have to be pumpkin pie. It comes around once a year at Thanksgiving, which is my favorite holiday. So many good family memories!!
My mother had many talents and professions. One of her many talents was a baker and caterer. However, it was her mother, my grandmother who taught me how to bake the most delicious pies. She taught me that it all started with a flaky crust made with lard. Since my grandfather and her grew apple trees, my favorite pie is her apple pie recipe. It was the cinnamon and the butter on top of the filling that made it irresistible!
MY FAVORITE IS PUMPKIN PIE THAT I MAKE —- I LOVE PEANUT BUTTER AND THIS RECIPE LOOKS DELISH — WILL HAVE TO TRY IT.
ZOE AND ELIZABETH YOU BOTH HAVE AWESOME SHOWS — LOVE WATCHING THEM — I LOVE BOTH OF YOUR PERSONALITIES.
Blueberry now and forever! It never disappoints!
Just give me pie! My feeling is really the only bad is the one not baked yet.
My favorite pie is pumpkin.
I love Lemon meringue pie, but my favorite peanut butter recipe is from a friend and I make them every Christmas- it is homemade peanut butter cups.
My Mom taught me to mix up pie crust when I was 7 years old. I love baking pies. Favorites—lemon, cherry and apple. Actually, I’ve never met a pie I didn’t like. The peanut butter meringue is one I will try.
I really do not have a favorite pie – I just love pie, whatever the flavor. If I had to pick just one it would probably be a Tart Cherry from Michigan cherries.
My favorite pie is German Chocolate Pie. It is the best.
Lemon Meringue Pie!! Honestly though, any pie!! And anything peanut butter! lol
My mom’s Apple pie!
I Love all Pies!! How can you choose just one!
I have never made a pie, yet! I think this winter will be the the year.
Kindly,
Deb
My favorite pie is Apple, I live in Wenatchee, Washington the Apple Capital of the World. I choose to use mix of 3/4 Granny Smiths and 1/4 Goldens. Granny’s add the right amount of tartness. My Granny that was with us for a short 86 years always had an apple pie or three in her freezer at all times. We always serve with vanilla ice cream. It’s the best!
It’s hard to beat a classic apple pie using 2 types of apples and plenty of lemon juice.
In the fall, Apple Pie with crumb topping. In the summer Lemon Meringue or Strawberrypie!
I love peanut butter anything and would love this new cookbook! My favorite pie of all time is coconut cream.
Greek Bougatsa (Custard Pie with Phyllo and ground Cinnamon) is my absolute favourite pie.
My favorite pie is my husband’s apple pie–he’s a wonderful pie baker!
Does Boston Cream Pie count as a pie??? LOL, it’s the perfect combo of cake, custard, gnache served in the shape of a piece of pie. If not, my all time favorite pie used to be pecan, but it’s become too sweet for my liking, so I’d have to say now it’s Coconut Cream.
My sister makes a peanut butter pie that is to die for. But it takes hours to make so I only made it once. But I will try this recipe to see if it is a quicker version!
Frozen lemonade pie is my favorite.
Banana cream pie or Dutch apple pie!
Love, love cherry pie. But also love anything with peanut butter!
My favorite pie is strawberry rhubarb with vanilla ice cream. I love the sweet/tart combo. I like my peanut butter in cookie form…..nothing fancy.
My sister lives in Carlsbad, NM and has pecan trees, so Pecan is my favorite then Huckleberry pie, both with homemade pie crust. Traditions for Thanksgiving. And I love watchIng Ranch to Table!
Hi Zoe!
French Silk pie and Caramel Apple Crisp pies are my favorite!
Has to be Pecan Pie! My husband grew up in
South Georgia and they had pecan trees in their yard. I am from the north and we pronounced it Pe-kahn. Those from Georgia say Pe-can (like a metal can for beans). Either way the are sweet and delicious. My nickname for our daughter is Pecan Pie as she is sweet and nutty
My favorite pie is my Mama’s sweet potato pie! It is delicious! I also love me some frozen Reese’s peanut butter cups! Yum!
I think nothing beats a wild blackberry pie!
Sweet potato pie with candied pecans!
I love a tart cherry pie the most but I also like tomato pie when tomatoes are in season.
My favorite pie is an apple pie with raisins and crumb topping. The raisins are simmered in some rum and sugar and allows to get syrupy. They really elevate the taste of the apples, and the crumb topping with brown sugar and butter completes the yummy deliciousness
Our family favorites pie,hands down, is fresh strawberry with a thin layer of cream cheese on the bottom of the pie shell. Tastes great and an added bonus is it helps keep the crust from getting soggy from the berries!
I love Dutch apple pie. All the crumbs on the top of the mound of delicious apples. I’m getting hungry just thinking about it.
I’m not sure there is any pie that I would turn down. But if I have to choose, it’s got to be cherry!
When I was a kid I had a cousin who made these amazing peanut butter chocolate squares. I was a kid and didn’t bake but when I see images of that it sends me back in time. I’ve since found a recipe and made it. It’s amazing how food can transport you to a time and place. I have a sweet tooth much to Drs dismay but I’ve been trying to up my baking game for a few years now. It’s just so fun.
My absolute pie is rhubarb and strawberry.
My husband LOVES LOVES a large peanut butter cookie with dark chocolate icing.
My favorite pie is Lemon Meringue with a close second of Peach.
Key lime is my favorite but this peanut butter meringue looks delicious!
I can’t choose just one pie, but even more than the pie itself I LOVE the pie recipes that my grandmothers passed down!
This Peanut Butter Meringue Pie sounds absolutely delicious. Can’t wait to have my grand children 18 and 16 , help me make this.
My favorite pie came from my grandmother on my moms side, passed down to mom. Grape Hull Pie, made with muscadine grapes. White or black grapes. It is a recipe that your hulls go into the recipe.
I have tasted many, in the DuplIn Co., N.C. area, no one could copy my mothers.
Zoe, thank you for your recipe s on your show, and cook books
Pumpkin Cream or Chocolate pie are my favorites. Yeah pie!
Brownie Pie
Houlihan’s Apple Strudel Pie is it as this is apple
picking time here!
Ask me in November or December and the
answers would be different.
Seems that I am rather fickle when in comes
to favorite pies.
Cherry pie and pecan pie. But any pie is good!
Peach Streusel
Love lemon pie!!
My fav PB recipe is Chocolate Peanut butter bars!!
I have made it countless times- Delish!!
Good ol fashioned chocolate cream pie!!
I love peach pie in the summer and pumpkin pie in the fall!
My favorite would have to be an old-fashioned blueberry pie. No fancy toppings or decorations. Just a lovely, light, flaky double crust and a fruit filling that doesn’t spill out the minute it’s lifted out of the pan and onto the plate. A scoop of vanilla ice cream is the ideal accompaniment.
Apple pie
My favorite is lemon meringue pie. As a child, I used to ask my mom for a lemon meringue pie instead of a cake. She always made awesome pies!
My favorite pie is key lime
My favorite pie is an apple pie with a custard base. I am always open to try new recipes.
I love a coconut custard pie and also an apple crumb, but this peanut butter pie looks divine! I’m a big fan of both Zoe Bakes and Ranch to Table and I
think both of you women are awesome!
I love a coconut custard pie or an apple crumb but this peanut butter
pie looks divine! I am a huge fan of Zoe Bakes and Ranch to Table. Both
of you women are awesome! Love your shows!
My favorite pie, filled with nostalgia, is Aunt Nellie’s blueberry pie. When I asked her for the recipe, she said “oh honey, there is no recipe – you just have to feel it.” She had made it for so many years, just knowing by sight and touch that it would be delicious!
I love the Chocolate Peanut butter Pie! It’s made by a local restaurant (The Cabbage Patch, Snohomish WA). Frankly ANY of their pies are amazing. All homemade and delicious.
My favorite pie depends on the season! Apple for Fall; lemon meringue for Spring, Blueberry for Summer, chocolate cream for Winter!
From Chess Pie through Pecan Pie (all favorites if placed on my dessert plate) my most favorite is BLACKBERRY CUSTARD PIE!!
So boring. I know, but my favorite pie is pumpkin!
My favorite pie is a lemon meringue pie!
My favorite is Peach Pie slightly warm with a flaky crust and vanilla bean ice cream especially in the summer when the peaches are ripe. On other end of the spectrum, I enjoy a Chocolate Cream Pie with fresh whip cream.
I love an old fashioned apple pie with extra spices and brown sugar just out of the oven with vanilla ice cream on top!
Okay, I’m definitely going to have to try this one! My all-time favorite pie is a good ol’ mixed berry pie, especially if it has a gorgeous lattice top for texture and beauty. Although, I also tried Zoe’s Perfect Peach Pie with peaches from my neighbor’s peach tree, and I have to say – it was hard to beat!
My fave pie is Lemon Meringue, with the meringue a mile high! So when I saw Peanut Butter Meringue, I ran right over to see it!
Chess pie! The simplicity of it is very comforting. Elizabeth’s peanut butter pie looks amazing and I know my family would love it. Her chocolate chip cookie with sea salt recipe is a family staple, as well as Zoe’s banana bread recipe. Off to make 2 loaves right now!
I love any kind of cream pie but my favorite is Coconut Cream Pie. This was also my dad’s favorite so I always made it for him during the holidays. When I was younger I could never get the cream to thicken and I would call my grandma for help to figure out what I was doing wrong. I’ve since mastered the pie and make it every Thanksgiving.
My two favorite pies are apple & coconut cream. They’re old fashioned but can’t be beat.
It’s hard to pick what pie is my favorite, I love a tall apple tart with a streusel. Blueberry is yummy. Lately it has been lemon meringue. However, theres a place in Bicknell, Utah that I always have to stop at when I’m out visiting family in Utah. They have a 4-slice sampler: pickle, pinto bean, oatmeal, and buttermilk…surprisingly they are really good !
A cherry pie to me is hard to beat. A favorite of peanut butter is my Grandmothers recipe for peanut butter cookies!
And I would like to add my husband and I really enjoy your cooking show!
My favorite pie is technically not a pie: Marion Burros’s recipe from the NYT for plum cake – divine!
I am from Tennessee so my favorite Southern pie is a chess pie. Got to have a homemade, flaky crust! My favorite peanut butter dessert is a peanut butter cake. ❤️
Apple pie with strudel topping for sure!
My mom made the best lemon meringue pie. I miss that. I love to make an apple pie this time of year.
Hello! My favorite pie is rhubarb (from my garden) and strawberries, with a flaky gluten free crust!
My favorite pie is Apple Cranberry. It is always on my table at Thanksgiving. I love peanut butter and often I bake cookies. I might try this recipe for Peanut Butter Meringue Pie, it looks delicions.
My favorite pie is apple pie but I also love mincemeat apple pie. So delicious!
My favorite pie is Key Lime and my favorite peanut butter dessert is a Reeses cup, but peanut butter pie sounds delicious!!
Does a galette count as a pie? I made an apple galette from apples I picked from my tree. It turned out beautiful. Made me so happy!
Key Lime is my all time favorite. Adult children love all things peanut butter. Can’t wait to try this recipe. Thanks for sharing
My favorite pie is my Grandma’s orange cranberry pie.
I love Lemon Meringue Pie as well reminds me of my mom I often recall the memory of her hand whipping the meringue for a long time…
A favorite dessert bar (handed down from my mom) is Peanut Butter Fingers – lots of peanut butter and chocolate chips.
My favorite is a sweet and tart cherry pie with a flaky sugared crust!
One of my favorite pies is Crunch-top Apple pie. It is a family favorite. Coconut cream comes in a close second.
My favorite pie is a Pumpkin pie with a Gingersnap crust! But I’m an equal-opportunity pie lover & would love to bake or try all sorts of pies!
My favorite pie is rhubarb – plain and simple. We eat as much of it as can when rhubarb is in season.
French Apple pie
My favorite pie is homemade pumpkin pie with homemade whipped cream with vanilla bean.
Love your show and I can’t wait to watch the next season.
My favorite is Pecan Pie. And I LOVE Ranch to Table and Zoe Bakes!
My favorite is blueberry rhubarb! SO GOOD! ☺️
My favorite pie is a tart cherry pie, double crusts. But I don’t know this peanut butter pie looks pretty incredible!!
My favorite peanut butter recipe is peanut butter cookies.
Thanks!
My favorite pie is lemon meringue.
Banana cream pie is my fave ♥️
Bourbon pecan pie! I make it every thanksgiving and it gets devoured in minutes.
My favorite pie is pumpkin with lots of spice and
Creamy whipped cream!!!
Favorite Pie…Green Chile Apple
Raisin pie-my aunt’s.
Cherry crumb pie!
Butterfinger pie! Just loads of scrumptious unhealthy calories!
My favorite pie is my Grandmother’s recipe for straight up Rhubarb Pie! It’s also my husband’s favorite. He once ate an entire rhubarb pie with his fingers driving from IL to Michigan!
I’m not a pie person but I love a French Silk Pie. I could eat the whole thing!!
Forever: sour cream apple pie. The mix of tangy apples, a great crust, sour cream and a buttery crunchy topping are out of this world. YUM.
Have to put in my vote for Marionberry Pie. Such a unique sweet/tart flavor that reminds me of growing up in the Pacific Northwest.
As for a peanut butter dessert, I recommend Smitten Kitchen’s Chocolate Peanut Butter layer cake. I made it for one birthday party and it now has a devoted fanbase spanning two counties.
My favorite pie is rhubarb custard.pie.
Pecan Pie…for sure!
Homemade apple pie with glaze
Hello Zoe and Elizabeth,
I love lemon meringue pie when I was young girl I didn’t like the Meringue part of the pie and my Grandmom would make me a pie without the meringue. Now I love the meringue on the pie. I watch your show and Elizabeth’s show and record them so I can watch with my 7 year old granddaughter who loves watching both shows.
I love a good mud pie. The peanut butter meringue pie looks delicious. I can’t wait to make this one.
My favorite pies are pumpkin and French silk. And for peanut butter dessert, I have to go with Reese’s peanut butter cheesecake. Thanks!!
Banana Cream Pie!!!
Peanut butter cream pie with a pretzel crust. Sweet and salty!
My Favorite Pie Is a Lemon Pie with sour cream Topping and my Second is A Tart Cherry Pie. Oh Well, I Love all Desserts. LOL
Zoe, my favorite pie would be a Bavarian Harvest Berry Pie with a Crumble topping. I serve it warm with a scoop of good vanilla ice cream or a luscious dollop of fresh whipped cream. The first time I tasted this pie was from a small farm bakery in Pennsylvania. I make one every fall to celebrate the changing of the season.
One of my favorite pies was my moms Rhubarb pie with a crumble topping!
My kid’s favorite is a Nutella pie. Would love to try and make the peanut butter pie and some other pies ❤️
Hi Zoe and Elizabeth
For me it’s Apple pie. It can be a regular apple pie, Dutch, caramel you name it I will eat it. Especially warm with vanilla ice cream.
I love no bake chocolate oatmeal cookies. I use chunky peanut butter for some crunch!
Cherry
I love a coconut cream pie & also apple crumb but this peanut butter pie looks delicious!
My favorite pie is lemon meringue.
Hands Down Favorite is Lemon Meringue. Tart and Sweet
You can never go wrong with a tart key lime pie slathered in mile high toasted meringue. That said, I do like the old school smoothness of a classic chess pie…smooth, unassuming and delicious! Pie-palooza!
grandma elizabeth lemon meringue and peach and her strawbery pies
My favorite is apple pie but I also love mincemeat apple pie. so delicious!
My grandmother’s butterscotch pie with meringue topping. It was delicious!
Lemonade meringue pie grandmom always made it the best. I try to make it but can’t get it like grandmom.
And I make peanut butter brownie cheesecake which my family calls the Beast
I pretty much Love any kind of pies, all of the pies I have just seen are amazing. I’m not the best pie maker-baker but my Mom was and my favorite pie she would make for me was her rhubarb strawberry pie…it was so good and thus makes me really miss her.
My all time favorite pie is apple streusel – apples in a flaky buttery crust, the most caramelly of apples and buttery crumb streusel topping!!
Hands down it is Key Lime Pie for me. Then apple, peach and pumpkin all come in a close second. Homemade is the best pie.
In middle school on Fridays the cafeteria made and sold Peanut Nibs. Kind of a Reese’s peanut butter cup in
“Blob” and so much better. Sold on a square of parchment paper. Every so often I try to make this. Honey, chopped peanuts and peanut butter dipped in chocolate! Yum!
Me and my family love peanut butter! Peanut butter rice crispies are an all-time favorite. I’d eat pie over cake any day! Favorites are banana, cream, Boston, cream and cherry!
Bourbon Pumpkin pie is my favorite. My husband loves everything that had peanut butter in it.
I like peanut butter chocolate chunk cookies!
I love choc chess pie!
I like cherry hand pies!
My absolute favorite peanut butter dessert recipe is thin and crispy peanut butter cookies. They are to die for. Thank you.
My favorite dessert growing up was, and still is, a homemade hot fudge using peanut butter that we make on the stovetop and then put over ice cream. You take Nesquik chocolate powder, milk and peanut butter and heat on the stove until it makes a hot fudge consistency. Then pour over vanilla ice cream. You can also use chocolate syrup in place of the chocolate powder and heat for a short time in the microwave.
My favorite is my raspberry meringue pie! It’s so tart and delicious!
I also really love peanut butter stuffed brownies, and the ones I make are a real pleaser!
Hi Zoe! I love too many pies to single out just one!
My favorite pie is coconut cream, with cherry a close second
Tart cherry pie with a crumb topping!
Hello Zoe and Elizabeth
For the whole of my life ( which is rather long now at 75!) my favourite pie has always been lemon meringue, but the meringue part, may well be the best as I am a sucker for Pavlova too. This peanut butter pie of yours Elizabeth looks amazing! I would never have thought of it myself but I can’t wait to try baking it because peanut butter is a staple in my daily life as well. Good luck to you both
Banana cream pie is my all time favorite.
Love both of your shows! No holiday is complete in family’s celebrations without our favorites – apple and also pumpkin chiffon pies.
Chocolate pecan pie! Drooling just thinking about it!
Cherry pie from Good Hart General Store in Michigan!!
Strawberry Rhubarb pie is my favorite, however I can’t say I’ve never met I pie I didn’t like! This one looks fantastic and can’t wait to try it!
Rhubarb pie. Peanut butter sheet cake.
My mom’s pumpkin chiffon pie.
Hi Zoe! My absolute favorite is my Great Grandma Bearman’s pumpkin pie recipe. Nothing fancy, but somehow beats the pants off of all other pumpkin pies!
French Silk Pie
My mother was a wonderful pie maker, so I have a special relationship with pies!! She was known for her home grown heirloom apple pies with flakey crust. My favorite was her fresh strawberry rhubarb pie. Wonderful memories!
I enjoy baking pies, also, and love hunting for good recipes.
French Silk Pie !
Have you ever heard of custard pie? When growing up on a farm with chickens, you sometimes have a plentiful egg supply. My mama would lovingly use those extra eggs in a custard pie. The crust was made from rendered lard, and shortening. Homemade, of course. The sprinkle of nutmeg on top of the egg mixture was my delight. Now, I haven’t eaten or made a custard pie since my mama passed, but I carry such sweet memories in my heart. ♡♡
My favorite pie among the many fruit pies
I love is a caramely peach praline which has the slightest hint of cinnamon. It’s the combination of sweet peaches and praline with that somewhat salty pie crust not to mention the softness of the fruit against the crunch of the crust. It’s totally perfect.
Apple cranberry pie in the fall with locally grow mix of tart and sweet apples!
Favorite pie……pecan, lemon. coconut cream. key lime, cherry, pumpkin, strawberry, blueberry, peach…wow, I love pie! Really enjoy both of your shows. Zoe, I love your desserts and Elizabeth, I love the ranch.
All Pie!!!! Yum
My favorite is strawberry rhubarb!
My favorite is strawberry rhubarb with vanilla ice cream
My Grandmother’s pear pie, made with the pears that grew on the tree in her yard. I loved helping roll put the dough for the crust, and eating the sugar, cinnamon and nutmeg coated pear pieces before the top crust was in place!
I love rhubarb custard.
My favorite peanut butter recipe is peanut butter fudge. My favorite pie recipe is a chocolate fudge pie that my mom makes. There seems to be a fudge theme here, haha.
Piled High Apple Pie
My favorite pie is a Vegan Chocolate cream pie. It would be amazing with a peanut butter layer!
There is nothing better than the All-American Apple Pie and I love to put a slice of cheddar cheese on top while it still served warm – or drizzle caramel all over it – serve it up with a true vanilla bean ice cream! ! ! ! I want some NOW!
love every deasert i have made from your show!
My favorite pie is apple with cranberries.
The Sweet Potato Pecan Pie from K-Paul’s in New Orleans (which sadly closed) was the best–thankfully the recipe is in Paul Prudhomme’s Louisiana Kitchen Cookbook.
Looks like a great book! My favorite pie is Key Lime
Apple pumpkin pie with a crumb topping!!
Truthfully, your peach pie recipe makes me weak in the knees. It has replaced apple pie as my fave!
It’s a toss up…coconut cream pie or rhubarb pie. I love either one!
I love good pies! Homemade and scumptious – like key lime, lemon meringue, rhubarb, apple. But I have a special love of Peanut Butter Pie. I had never had one until I went to college at the University of Alabama in Tuscaloosa. A small diner near campus made the most delicious peanut butter pie, with a high, fluffy meringue. It is a food memory that I have never been able to replicate. The restaurant no longer exits, and I can’t recall the name, but that peanut butter pie is legendary in my mind. It was no overly sweet, but creamy, and the meringue topped it like a crown.
It’s a toss up…coconut cream pie or rhubarb pie. I love either one!
Peach pie is my favorite ❤️
Cherry Pie is my #1. As a kid I always got one for my birthday instead of a cake. . This Peanut Butter recipe looks amazing, can’t wait to try it!
Hello Zoe and Elizabeth,
I love watching both of your shows. Zoe I Can’t wait to see Season 4. I hope it airs soon. My favorite pie is a rhubarb and raspberry pie.
I love peanut butter pie! My husband and I love Elizabeth’s show and yours as well Zoe! We would love a copy of her cookbook!
My favorite pie is a Marionberry pie. Peanut butter with dark chocolate is a winner in anything! I love both your shows!
My mom would make a peanut butter pie that was similar to this recipe, and everyone loved it! ❤️She was even featured in the local newspaper with her peanut butter pie. Now I make it for my grandkids..
My favorite is Peanut Butter Pie with a bit of chocolate on top !!!
My most favorite pie is a chocolate pudding pie with homemade whipped cream.
I love a pecan- pumpkin pie this time of year!!
This pie looks amazing and I love chocolate and apple pies, also.
My favorite pie is Apple with cheddar cheese. Win or loss I will be getting the cookbook, I love peanut butter and will be baking this soon.
Peanut butter cookies are my favorite!
Dutch apple pie–best of both apple dessert worlds: pie crust and oat-y crumble! Also love my great-aunt’s cranberry-pecan pie.
Pumpkin cream cheese pie is one of my top favorites. Pie is my favorite treat!!
This peanut butter pie looks amazing!!! My favorite pie is a toss up between a nice warm s’mores pie or a pumpkin pie with fresh cream!
I lov watching Magnolia Network!!! Ranch to table makes rustic elegant delicious food!!!!!! I get excited to try and make her recipes. (My husband also enjoys the recipes from the show I make .)
My favorite pie is her classic lemon meringue. But I also love her Peach Buckle!!!
Peanut butter is my favorite food, so it would be worth getting the book for the peanut butter pie recipe alone!
My favorite pie is Pumpkin! My favorite peanut butter recipe is for Buckeyes!
Hello
My favorite peanut butter recipe is my Nanny’s peanut butter fudge. I’ve tried to replicate it with her recipe, even, but it’s never as good. My favorite pie comes with the change of the seasons. Spring brings cherry pie; summer lemon and lime and peach pies; fall apple, pecan; winter brings hearty pies like chocolate and peanut butter!
Ooh, that’s a tough one, I love pie!! Probably Strawberry Rhubarb! My favorite peanut butter dessert was this 3-layer peanut butter cake I made with a maple buttercream frosting in between the layers and then chocolate ganache drizzled on the top! Delish!
Ohhh, that looks so yummy! My favorite pie to make is a caramel apple pie with a crumb topping. I sent one to school for pi day on 3/14 and tit was a hit!
I love lemon meringue pie, especially from Pilgrim Kitchen in Belmont CA. I have moved out of the area, and I think before I moved, they closed. Their lemon meringue pie was so good. It was more on the sweeter side vs. a real tart version. It was to die for! I love peanut butter and a peanut butter pie, sounds wonderful!
I have fond family memories of Chocolate Cream Pie! It was my grandpa’s favorite and he was my favorite person! We so enjoy both of you ladies and get excited when you have a new show. Thanks!
Apple pie!!!
I love pie, any kind but rhubarb and apple are my faves!!!! Once I had to bake 55 apple pies in one day for an event !
I just LOVE both of you and would love to visit some day and bake together !!
There are so many to choose from but I’d say an apple pie. It reminds me of the days baking them with the kids after going apple picking and having it with a large scoop of ice cream. What a treat!
Fav pie – Pizza + Chocolate Ganache Tart
Fav PB – Peanut Butter Cups + PB Chocolate Ganache Tart
Dutch apple pie 🙂
Lucy’s Peanut Butter Brownie’s by Joanna Gaines featured in her Magnolia Table cookbook!
My favorite is Cherry pie, but Apple pie is a close 2nd favorite. And love love peach pie recipe you made. I tried the recipe and got so many compliments. So yummy!
Apple Pie!
My favorite pie is chocolate with whipped cream.
Hi! My favorite pie is Ree (The Pioneer Woman)’s chocolate pie! Thanks for this giveaway!
My favorite pie is Pumpkin Pie. It has to be made with my homemade crust! Yum!!!
My mum’s rhubarb cream pie.
I love Pean Pie, but only my family’s old recipe.
Coconut Cream pie is my all-time favorite! Mom used to make me that for my birthday instead of cake.
My favorite is Chocolate with Meringue or Coconut with Meringue or – well, most any kind of pie! Love your show and have gained many good tips watching you!
My favorite peanut butter dessert recipe, hands down, is the peanut butter, marshmallow brownies from Sarah Keiffer’s 100 Cookies! It’s the perfect mix of chocolate and other flavors. My whole family loves them!
My favorite pie is pecan, and my favorite peanut butter dessert is Peanut Butter cookies, my Grandmother made the best
I love the Buckeye pb candies and there is a pb cream pie that I also love – the egg yolks make the cream filling and the whites create a meringue topping. PB crumble is layered with the filling.
I love coconut cream pie!
I love a blueberry crumb!
Cherry peach’s be blueberry pie with ice cream
Peach cherry and blueberry with ice cream
Anything with chocolate in it serves me well in a pie!
My mother who was born and raised in Germany made us Kuchen which is a cake and pie. Oh how I miss her baking. However, 1 year visiting my sister in Stone Mountain Ga we went out for dinner and I had my first Bourbon Pecan Pie and it was delicious. I wish I got he recipe from them as most pecan pies have no bourbon. Btw, I haven’t missed one show yet of Ranch to Table love her and love your show as well.
Oh my, this book sounds so enchanting! My favorite peanut butter recipe is Peanut Butter Crispy Bars from Baked: New Frontiers in Baking. It is a decadent version of Rice Krispy Treats, and so good! Thank you for this giveaway!
An apple pie recipe I got years ago and make it several times during apple season.
Peanut butter blossoms are my favorite and this recipe was passed down from my mom.
Love a peanut butter cookie or brownie.
My favorite peanut butter recipe is “Peanut Butter Brownie Trifle”. It is DELICIOUS!! Also, it is very rich, so just scoop out a little to start, then go from there.
Peanut butter blossoms – my grandma always made them for Christmas. There might be a family revolt if someone does not show up with them for the cookie table. My brother would be happy with a personal plate of these over any other gift!
I love a simple crispy peanut butter cookie!
My son’s coconut cream pie! Though after baking peanut butter meringue, I just might change my mind.
My most favorite pie is Blueberry followed by Apple . Thanks!!!
My favorite is home made Pecan Pie…just can’t resist it.
Love your show and Ranch to Table, also.
Peanut butter and cherry PIe. the ultimate PB and J. Make a no bake PB and freeze it. The spread on cherry filling and top with PB whip cream
I love coconut cream pie! Especially the recipe from from Dahlia’s Bakery in Seattle.
My wife makes an amazing raspberry cream cheese pie that is out of this world!
White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Pie with a homemade crust mmmmm
My favorite pie is the good old fashioned pumpkin pie.
Weird but Concord Grape Pie. Slip skins off, cook and strain pulp, add skins. So good with vanilla ice cream. I love peanut butter balls (Buckeyes)
Fruits of the forest/mixed berry pie, with strawberries, blueberries, blackberries, raspberries, and rhubarb, with a flakey pie crust
My favorite is the mile high apple pie!!
My favorite is the mile high apple pie!!
This is a very hard question to answer! It’s a toss up between cherry pie and nectarine-raspberry. Pie is the perfect dessert and breakfast food!
I love your recipes Zoe! Keep up the beautiful work you do.
I’m a peach pie type of person!
In my mind, nothing beats a sweet potato pie with whipped cream. I like my peanut butter straight up on a pb&j sandwich. I’ve never tried it in a pie. Would be interesting.
My favorite pie is French silk. My mom’s favorite pie in the whole world is coconut cream, made by my grandma. I don’t remember this pie, but I do remember my grandma’s blackberry cobbler. My mom says my grandma was the best pie maker. If her pies were anything like her cobbler, I would have to agree. Thank you for reminding me how love is the best ingredient.
I just made the “salted caramel peanut butter cake” from Yossy Arefi’s “Snacking Cakes” and it was amazing! The whole family adored it.
My favorite pie is cherry pie! So delicious!!
Pecan Pie is my favorite for Fall and Winter, while Key Lime Pie is my go-to for Spring and Summer months!
I absolutely love peanut butter brownies where you make regular brownies and drop peanut butter cookie dough on top. Just wow!!!
Apple pie with crumb topping.
Homemade Lemon Meringue Pie with high meringue❤️
Im also a ranch girl but from Oklahoma! My grandmother always made Coconut Creme pies for any church social. People would grt her pie first, before it was gone, then head back to the pot-luck table! She made the best and taught me well… therefore, Coconut Creme is my favorite!
I have a tie for best pie. I love Banana Cream and Apple. I couldn’t decide so made it a tie!
Love, Love, Love, Peanut butter cookies! They’re just the right amount of peanut buttery sweetness after a meal. Who am I kidding, after every meal!!!
My favorite pie is a Peanut Butter Pie my mother (an amazing baker) made often when we were kids–it had a peanut butter filling, whipped cream topping, and the best part–peanut butter crumblies on top!
My favorite pie is a tart cherry pie. Yes, serve it with some ice cream too!
This pie looks amazing! I love peanut butter! My favorite is peanut butter bars.
My favorite pie is KEY LIME with a meringue although I will eat any pie that’s served to me! All year long!
My favorite pie is coconut cream with real whipped cream on top!
Peanut butter custard with chocolate ganache. OMG
My favorite pie is Strawberry Rhubarb Jalapeno pie that my husband makes completely from scratch ~ so delicious!
Peanut butter cream pie IS my favorite!
I love an apple pie, I use a mix of granny smith and honey crisp, peel about 4 each of them, toss with a cup of unbleached organic sugar a handful of heritage wheat flower a tablespoon or two cinnamon, a teaspoon of freshly ground nutmeg. I use a crust of 3 cups of heritage wheat flower and a half cup of chopped butter and a teaspoon and a half of sea salt. Cut butter in then add water till its a workable dough but not too much! Roll it out place the apples in the crust dot with 5 pats of butter, cover with crust then sprinkle turbinado sugar on top. Bake at 425 for about an hour, lay foil on top to prevent overbrowning during the last 30 min or so – take out when the house smells delicious and the juices are bubbly and a bit syruppy (very technical I know)
The classic and my favourite Lemon Pie
Plumb with almond crème pie with amaretti cookie crust
Hello. My favorite peanut butter dessert is these dark chocoolate cupcakes with peanut butter frosting from Sally’s Baking Addiction, they are AMAZING! I also love me a good apple crumble pie. Especially with some vanilla ice cream.
Sweet potato pie with lattice top.
Ohhhh I love Key lime pie!! But I also love peanuts butter chocolate chip cookies. I’d love to win this cookbook and try new recipes for my family. Please pick me.
French Silk is my favorite pie. At Thanksgiving, I have to make 2 of them because they are so popular at our dinner!
Chocolate Cream is my favorite! But it’s so hard to find the real deal…no instant pudding and Cool Whip! For any holiday, my grandma would ask everyone what their favorite was and then she would make them. Every one. From scratch. I have not mastered pie making…I guess I need this book!! 🙂
I love pecan pie –..although i love it all–especially the memories of the pies my mother made….
Old school Lemon Chess Pie… ironically I’m always drawn to rich dark chocolate but I’ll veer away for a really well spiced pumpkin slice or a lemon chess slice.
I love all pies but especially apple pie! Thanks for doing this giveaway!
My favorite pie is a vegan chocolate pie! Itt would be amazing with a peanut butter addition. I will have to think about it. Yum!
My favorite peanut butter dessert is Peanut Butter cups. My husband LOVES them and its SOOOOOO easy. There is no baking involved.
Sweet potato pie!
Peanut butter buckeyes…nearly any version…it’s the magic of peanut butter and chocolate in a mouth-poppable morsel!
This peanut butter pie looks incredible! I love cream pies the most – chocolate, coconut or banana, and I’ve always wanted to make a peanut butter pie. This one could be the one I finally make!
Rhubarb Custard and Sour Cherry – two favorites!
My favorite is rhubarb with grated orange rind. A close second is apple with green tomato. Both recipes my Mother got from her Great Granma.
My favorite pie is lemon meringue, but why have I never thought of peanut butter meringue?!
Peanut butter mousse in a chocolate dome. I love to add whipped egg whites to the peanut butter/cream cheese mixture to make it super fluffy. It’s like an upside down Reese’s peanut butter cup cloud!
Pecan pie!!!!!!
my favorite is a dark chocolate pie tart
My Mom’s boysenberry pie with berries grown by my Dad. This pie looks amazing.
My favorite pie is coconut cream and my favorite peanut butter dessert is a peanut butter sandwich cookie I make. Love your recipes. Would love to win this beautiful book!
My favorite pie is Pecan Pie & my favorite peanut butter dessert is Peanut Butter Cake
Sweet potato pie with a butterfly shaped tiny scoop of vanilla icecream.
Savor this deliciousness on the sand watching the sea.
Pure heaven.
I love an apple pie with a homemade crust. But I also like adding a twist like bourbon or apple cider when making it. I love your show and your recipes!
I have 2 favorite pies: apple pie and mixed berry pie.
I cannot resist a Key Lime Pie
Classic apple pie for me. I also love old fashioned peanut butter bars with chocolate.
Pumpkin sweet potato pie!!
I think my favorite peanut butter dessert is King Arthur’s Magic in the Middle Cookies — such a great combination of chocolate and peanut butter.
strawberry rhubarb!
Any pie my gramma made! Pie of love! But a favorite peanut better pie… chocolate cookie crust with peanut better later then like a brownie on top with peanut butter sauce and chips on top.. sooo yum!
Rhubarb custard made by my mom with anything peanut butter a close second!
Happy Thursday! My absolute favorite pie is strawberry rhubarb with streusel topping and homemade whipped cream to finish it off!
My favorite pie is a Rhubarb Cream pie with Meringue topping. My Mother in law was the best pie maker & she gave me the recipe.
Zoe and Elizabeth – I love both of your programs on the Magnolia Network! My favorite pie is a spicy Mexican chocolate pumpkin pie.
I’m a pumpkin, pecan or a mile high apple pie gal….and homemade is the best!! The most requested birthday pie in my family is a key lime and for cake, a chocolate bourbon cake. So many options!
My favorite pie comes from the old LBJ Ranch in Texas. It’s a pecan pie that will blow everything out of the water. Over the years, I’ve made a few tweaks to the original, and have even been taken orders for them!
Hi! My hometown was a very small one in Western Kansas. We lived on a farm 14 miles from town. Even though the town was only 500 residents on a good day, there was the a cafe with the best pies. On Sunday, my folks would stay in town after church to visit and lunch at the cafe. This is where I discovered my favorite pie was peanut butter cream. I have never been able to duplicate that taste, so I was very excited you shared your recipe on Zoe’s site. I hope to try it soon. Thank you!!
I make a peanut butter pie that is my sons & my favorite. It’s his birthday pie.
Hello,
My favorite pie is a homemade apple pie. I also fell in love with the peanut butter cream pie too. I never had it until I visited Alabama and it was amazing.
My mom’s apple pie!
Peach pie has to be a favorite of mine. Doesn’t hurt that I live among Palisade peach orchards in SW Colorado!
PBJ is pretty much all I know regarding peanut butter…well, cookies too. Never made or had a peanut butter dessert.
Strawberry rhubarb with a crumb topping is my favorite pie – especially in July for breakfast 🙂
The peanut butter pie from the Ark Restaurant – it was located in Ilwaco, Washington. Sadly it has been closed for years now.
My favorite pie is coconut cream pie!
My favorite pie is peavh cherry.
My family loves oatmeal peanut butter cookies! Those would be our PB favorite. Can’t wait to try the PB pie and check out the new Ranch Table cookbook!
I bake and eat pie typically during the Fall and Winter holidays. A bourbon pecan pie from a recipe from the now defunct Gourmet magazine is a fave and a simple, back of the can pumpkin pie is so good. I also love coconut cream pie and a chocolate cream pie. Hmmm, then there is a cherry pie in the Summer…Apple pie too. There’s always a reason to eat pie!
I’m making your Apple Pie recipe today for a birthday! It’s my fave! I love both of your shows!♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
Hello Zoe and Elizabeth!
So many pies so little time…I would have to say my all time fav is Marionberry Pie with homemade ice cream.
The Ark Restaurant which was located in Ilwaco, Washington made the best peanut butter pie. Sadly it has been closed for years now.
I love peanut butter! My favorite peanut butter recipe is Brownie Bottom Peanut Butter Pie! We made this around Thanksgiving and anytime we need a peanut butter fix.
This is a tough choice but I think I love Key Lime Pie. I love the tangy and sweet. There’s no other pie quite like it. My favorite
My favorite pie is blueberry!!!!
I never met a pie I didn’t love but I’ll have to say that shoo-fly pie is at the top of my comfort food list.
Thank you for this offer.
Looks delicious but my favorites remain fruit and berry pies.
My favorite pie is a Jingle Berry Pie .. raspberries,blackberries, blueberries and strawberry. It is delicious and so pretty at Christmas.
My most favorite pie is A Homemade Cherry Pie
My favorite pie is Chocolate pudding pie and my favorite peanut butter dessert is a peanut butter bar our local school makes.
Your chocolate peanut butter pie and perfect peach pies! I could never make a pie until I discovered you!!
I love pumpkin pie, gives me all the warm fuzzies!
This recipe looks delicious and reminds me of the peanut butter buckeyes my mom makes every Christmas! For a favorite pie, I’d go with a coconut cream pie with chocolate cookie crust. I also love a fresh strawberry rhubarb pie in the summer.
I adore the simplicity of a crisp peanut butter cookie…but if we are talking pies, I have to go with boysenberry pie from the coastal town of Florence Oregon. Best ever!!!
I grew up a few miles from her ranch! Wonderful to see her success! My favorite pie is banana, although I rarely eat it because no one in the family likes it but me!
My favorite pie has to be the classic pumpkin pie which my mom made every thanksgiving. As for my favorite peanut butter cookie also has to be the Peanut Butter Cookie with Reese butter candy in the center which I only make at Christmas. Needless to say they are the first cookie to disappear.
Chocolate cream pie
This pie would be a great complement to any meal!
It is so hard to pick just one, but if I had to choose, I would go with French Silk pie. Oh, and my mom’s pecan pie.
Hi Zoë, I love Chess pie…a decidedly Southern dessert. But I’ve also had some delicious peanut butter pie, so would love to win this beautiful cookbook.
Thanks!
Fresh Blueberry pie is my favorite- with lots of freshly whipped cream on top! It’s wonderful because it has thickened (&sweetened blueberries) mixed with fresh blueberries- so refreshing and delicious!
Oh just thinking about it! My favorite pie has to be my great Aunt Hazel’s chocolate pie with meringue piled high on top and toasted to perfection. The flaky crust with the delicious chocolate filling all together is just a warm memory in my heart and my tummy. This is such a family favorite that it gets requested for instead of a birthday cake this pie…so a birthday pie! Peanut butter, ummm, yes please. I am a peanut butter lover even on a spoon!
Love making a rhubarb pie in the early days of summer!
The first peanut butter pie recipe I made is still my favorite, and it was the one you posted in honor of Mikey. You introduced me to Jennie and her blog with that post as well, and I made that pie all the time- including during a prolonged time we spent on an island in Belize in a time when a variety of fresh dairy products were hard to find. I scoured the island for all of the ingredients and friends fell in love with the pie. One friend requested I make it for his wedding 🙂
Actually, I think this might be my new favorite!
I LOVE pecan pie! I used to really not like any fruit pies but I’m coming around to them. But pecan pie will always have my heart.
Where do I start with favorite pie!! All your pies are delicious!!! Straws/rhubarb pie is our family’s favorite!!
My favorite is strawberry rhubarb – my grandma always made them for me. Brings back wonderful memories when I make them now.
My favorite pie is German Chocolate. Might have to make one this weekend.
My favorite pie is pie. but one stands out from my childhood- it was called German Chocolate pie and it came from the House of Pies in Houston Texas. Chocolate cream pie with coconut flakes and sliced almonds all throughout. The perfect mix of creamy chocolate and crunch. It was delicious!!
Favorite Pie is easy, my Grandma’s Apple Pie with a water whip crust. The key is the apples, only McIntosh!
As for peanut butter, I love pretty much EVERYTHING with PB, but there is a cake at a local restaurant chain in RI (where I grew up). Money from each cake purchase or even from each SLICE, provides a donation to the Hasbro Children’s Hospital. It is known as the “Giving Cake”. This amazingly delish four-layered cake is a combo of peanut butter and chocolate. Here’s a link to read more about it: https://www.greggsusa.com/the-giving-cake
One I don’t make very often is my favorite my grandmother’s butterscotch pie. It was my father’s too. My next favorite is golden peach pie, a recipe also from my grandmother.
Our top two are Atlantic Beach pie and Pumpkin pie from a lovely older lady in our community. She makes the most delicious crust and the filling is heavenly
Dutch apple pie made with Wolf River and Honeycrisp apples!
Every Thanksgiving I make a Bourbon Chocolate Chip Pecan Pie – by far my favorite pie (my family loves it too!)
I absolutely love a chunky chocolate & peanut butter cup ice cream!
My family loves watching Ranch to Table, and I am so excited to read Elizabeth’s cookbook.
Love love peanut butter cookies!!!
My favorite pie is pumpkin pie. Although, this peanut butter pie could become a new favorite. It looks delicious!
My favorite pie is a coconut cream pie! It’s such a perfect dessert for spring and summer.
For fall, the go-to pie are a Dutch apple pie or a simple apple pie with a hefty scoop of vanilla ice cream.
For the winter months, I look forward to a gorgeous decadent French silk pie.
My favorite pie is Boston Cream Pie. Yummy!! Followed by Peach Pie, a close 2nd.
My favorite pie is dutch apple- with apples picked from my backyard! LOVE my orchard!
Most favored peanut butter dessert is ‘Oh Henry Bars’, a recipe from my youngest brother’s grade school class many, many years ago. It has been a favorite since childhood and I turn 70 this December. Great as gift too.
Any cream pie! And this recipe looks delicious!!
I absolutely love Banana Cream Pie! Really any cream pie, Coconut, Chocolate any pie that is filled with smooth creaminess.
I make a chocolate hazelnut espresso banana pie with a homemade peanut butter whipped cream
Peach Pie and love anything peanut butter and chocolate!
My favorite pie has always been strawberry rhubarb. The mixture of tart and sweet is delicious. Complimented with vanilla ice cream is just devine.
I love a mixed berry pie but also lemon meringue! But how could you forget french silk….why are there so many good pies?
My favorite pie is lemon meringue, the tart lemon with the pillowy meringue is the absolute best!
I love a homemade blueberry or cherry pie, as well as, a peanut butter pie! I am a fan of Ranch To Table and agree with you about her glamour side as well as her down to earth, get tough and in the dirt side.
My favorite pie is a lime pie with a graham cracker crust. My family loves it and I’m expected to bring it every Thanksgiving.
Coconut cream pie topped with whipped cream, not meringue.
My Moms Lemon Meringue Pie made with condensed milk
My favorite pie is a lemon cream pie but must be homemade. I do not care for weird whipped cream substitutes.
My favorite pie is my
Moms Cottage Cheese pie with a cup of hot tea! So delicious on a cool fall day! However anything with peanut butter and chocolate is always a winner with me!
My fav pie is any flaky crust pie, which I have not perfected. Love making pies, and love watching the artful talent of making crusts but peanut butter is yummy in any form.
My favorite pie is “PIE”… just about any flavor. But I guess, ultimately, it would be the classic Lemon Meringue with the fluffy meringue, tart curd and flaky pastry, my mouth is watering as I type this!
I actually love apple pie the most, obviously more in the cooler season. I love it topped with plain vanilla ice cream.
As for peanut butter I love anything mixed with chocolate. The first would be a pure chocolate cake with peanut butter frosting, yum. I love Buck eyes candies, they just hit so differently!
I am diabetic so when I get to indulge my go to would be the chocolate cake with peanut butter frosting. It is such a rich and rewarding treat!
My favorite pie is apple pie, especially warm and topped with vanilla ice cream. I love peanut butter in cookies and brownies!
Anything Peanut Butter, especially cheesecake!
My grandmother’s peanut butter squares. This old recipe is still a crowd pleaser no matter where is goes. My grown children still request it regularly. The ease of no-bake, peanut butter and rich chocolate topping is always an amazing combination!
My favorite pie is double Chocolate mocha pudding pie! It’s as decadent as it sounds. Thank you for sharing your experience with Elizabeth and giving away her cookbook. That is so gracious of you! Love Zoë bakes!
Warm apple pie with a scoop of homemade vanilla ice cream! A delicious American pleasure!
My favorite is butterscotch pie! My mom spent years trying duplicate her mom’s recipe as best that she could remember as she was 12 when her mom passed so there were many variations. One time she was going to teach all of us how to make it and told us to bring our recipes to take notes on. Each of us had a difficult recipe than the one she was using to teach with!
My mother makes a peanut butter pie that is a favorite of many of her family and friends. She adds peanut butter to her normal cream pie recipe. That’s it! I won’t say peanut butter pie is my favorite, but I do like it.
Strawberry rhubarb pie is my absolute favorite! Also, chocolate cake with peanut butter frosting is delicious too.
i love a good cherry pie!!! thanks
Key Lime Pie
Not artificial stuff you buy in the store
Homemade is always the way to go
Secondly, Cherry Cheesecake
Fresh strawberry rhubarb pie and fresh blackberry are tied for first! My niece makes a mean chocolate peanut pie for the holidays. Chocolate peanut butter is my favorite flavor combination.
I love peanut butter sheet cake. Our cooks made it for us in our sorority house, and it has remained a favorite ever since.
My favorite pie is blackberry! Favorite peanut butter treat is a buckeye!
Hi Zoe and Elizabeth – loving both of your shows. My favorite pie is pretty much anything with a big pile of meringue on the top!
I absolutely love tart cherry pie!
Lemon Meringue with clouds of egg whites on top!
My favorite pie is a chocolate pecan pie. It is to die for!
I thoroughly enjoy Elizabeth’s show and her recipes! She’s very down to earth and completely reflects that area of California. Her recipes and style are simple and delicious. All her fresh fruit pies, hand pies and desserts are terrific. Then there’s Zoe with her simple flair baking. These ladies offer wonderful contrast and interest. Each make baking fun and support family values. Thank you!
My grandmas slab apple pie all day! Yum!
Whiskey Caramel Sweet Potato Pie ….. mmmmm
Favorite pie is a new one I made this summer:) Mixed berry with a tradition bottom crust and a crumbled oat/pecan topping, delicious!!
My FAVORITE pie was a cherry pie my friend made for another friend’s wedding! She had a whole table full of wedding pies all made by friends. It was divine, simple and delicious! I have never quite had one like it since!
Once a year I make a mile high apple pie, it is heaven.
Congratulations Zoe & Elizabeth on your successful shows!! I have been inspired by both of you!
Love classic recipes such as chocolate cream pie, apple pie!
Husband loves coconut cream & strawberry rhubarb pies!
We both love a good peanut butter cookie!
I love peanut butter and sweetened condensed milk mixed together and used to fill chocolate chip cookie bars – absolutely amazing and ooey gooey.
My favorite pie was and will always be my grandmothers lemon merengue pie. It kills me that I don’t have her recipe, but I have the memories. 😉
Wow that looks delicious! I love a classic peanut butter cookie!
Chocolate silk pie is an all an all time favorite!
Any & all fruit pie!!
You and Elizabeth are my new favorite cooking shows. My favorite pie is hands down a pecan pie
I love a good peanut butter and chocolate pie….! Much like a cream pie, with the flavors of both mixing and loving it! 🙂
My favorite pie is a fresh peach pie with bourbon whipped cream
My favorite pie is coconut custard pie. I grew up in Belize and I’ll always go for the coconut.
Love your recipes and pics!
My favorite is a French Silk Pie
Deserted island pie with crumble topping is my all time favorite!!
Peach Pie is my favorite!
My favorite is Dutch apple pie but I haven’t tried peanut butter pie !
Key lime pie or peanut butter cookies but I can’t wait to try a merengue pie!
Love a good old fashioned apple pie in the fall!
Hi Zoe,
My favorite pie is apple, a recipe from long ago! I always use Cortland apples and cook them down slightly before adding all the yummy sugar, cinnamon, butter pieces & then baking it. Thanks for the chance to win Elizabeth Poett’s new cookbook!
Had to grow our own bushes to make a family favorite, red currant pie!
My favorite pie is Key Lime meringue.
My favorite pie is whatever pie someone I love asks me to make! I love sharing and it makes me feel special to make someone feel special.
My absolute favorite pie is pecan pie, but I love a good apple slab pie and I’m making one this weekend for a family gathering. Love both of these shows!
My favorite pie is Chocolate Silk pie!
My favorite pie is coconut cream.
Lemon Meringue!
My favorite pie was my grandmothers extra pie dough scraps. She would sprinkle it with sugar and cinnamon or throw a pecan in there.
Does that count as a pie? 😀
My favorite pie would be a Buckeye pie which is a peanut butter cream pie topped with chocolate ganache. Anything peanut butter!!
My go to holiday pie is a chocolate angel pie. It consists of a meringue crust filled with a deep dark chocolate moose and topped with whipped cream.
Sweet potato pie is our family favorite.
I love my grandma’s oatmeal pie. It is her version of a pecan pie but with oatmeal instead of pecans. It is great! I make it in memory of her every Thanksgiving.
I miss Minneapolis
Key Lime pie
My favorite pie is lemon meringue but this peanut butter pie looks amazing and I can’t wait to wow folks at my next party with this pie!
My favorite pie is Pecan! And I love Monster cookies with lots of peanut butter!
My favorite pie is North Carolina Atlantic pie. Deliciously tart, sweet and salty.
My favorite pies are French Silk, Coconut Cream and Banana
I was never a pie person until the cheesecake pumpkin pie came into my life❤️a layer of cream cheese and a layer of pumpkin pie with spiced waffer crust.
It’s got to be deep dish pumpkin praline pie. Now you have me thinking of adding a toasty meringue on top!!
I am a pie lover through and through, but my “fav” peanut butter dessert is a drop cookie we make only at Christmas time with peanut butter and cornflakes that is crunchy, light and full of peanutty goodness.
Hi Zoe!
Thanks for the contest. 🙂 My favorite is peanut butter chocolate bars. What can go wrong when you combine the 2 best ingredients ever!
Definitely a tie between blackberry pie (as a kid I would pick the berries in our yard, my mom would bake the pie) and key lime!
I’m not a huge pie fan honestly but I do like the occasional slice of lemon meringue or chocolate silk pie. Oh and peanut butter pie too. This one looks incredible!
I love banana cream pie.. or apple…or pecan…or…hmmm…. apparently, I can not choose! I have to say Zoë, your recipe for pie crust and peach pie in Season 3, amazing!! Thank you!
My most craveable pie is salted caramel apple pie!
My favorite pie is apple! I love a classic!
Hello! I love a classic cherry pie, and my favorite peanut butter dessert is simple: chunky, sweet-salty peanut butter swirled into vanilla ice cream!
My favorite pie is double crust peach pie made with sweet local Fredericksburg Texas peaches. Topped with my homemade vanilla bean ice cream. A pie enjoyed during the fresh peach season!!!
I love anything made with peanut butter.
My favorite pie is Cocont Cream Pie !
My favorite peanut butter recipe is for cookies. Recipe is an old one from an old Joy of Cooking cookbook. But my favorite pie is pecan pie. love the crunch, love the texture and love the sweetness, it has it all.
Pecan Pie.
My favorite pie is the Hula Hula Pie from Hawaii all those layers is just dreamy. For peanut butter pie it would be the simple recipe from Ree Drummond that I use for ice box peanut butter pie. Simple, delicious and easy to make.
Nothing beats a single-crust fresh peach pie when the fruit is in season! A bit of OJ brings out the juiciest peach flavor. Top w/meringue, whipped cream, ice cream … or just a big spoon. 🙂
My favorite pie is apple or my Grannies lemon meringue pie they both are close to my heart.. And my favorite peanut butter dessert would be my Mommas skillet cookies.. so wonderful !!
Though cherry pie is high on my list, I’ve always had a hankering for a good mincemeat pie. Yum, yum!
My favorite pie is blackberry. It’s hard to choose, close runners up are cherry and pecan pies
We have 2 favorite pies – a Rhubarb custard pie that is my Nana’s recipe and an Upside Down Chocolate Mousse pie. Thanks for the opportunity.
My favorite pie is rhubarb custard! While not the most American classic or popular, it is a welcome spring dessert signaling the change in seasons, especially after a long Minnesotan winter.
I love simple, classic peanut butter cookies.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cheesecake
My favorite pie is blueberry pie with crust on top.
My favorite pie is all pie! Pie over cake any da. But my all time favorite is Strawberry pie! When I was little my god mother made two strawberry pies for my birthday, one for me and one for everyone else. Still could eat a whole one of those if given the opportunity!
My favorite is a fresh peach pie with a crumble topping served with a caramel drizzle and fresh vanilla bean whipped cream!
My favorite to make is A Pear Almond Pie. It is my moms favorite
Oh, my favorite peanut butter treat is a classic peanut butter cookie, warm from the oven.
My favorite pie is Dutch apple, with caramel ice cream on the side!
Hi Zoe!
My fave pie is Chocolate Peanut Butter Whipped Cream pie !!! AH-MAZE-ING!!!!!
My favorite pie is pecan pie with chocolate chips. It’s a crowd favorite.
Pecan Pie. But, I had one made by a caterer in Austin, Texas a few years ago that was NOT made with Karo syrup. In fact, I don’t know what she made it with – but it was the best pecan pie I ever ate. And, of the hundreds that attended the event at my workplace, everyone was commenting on how wonderful it was.
I’d be interested in Zoe finding out – was it was Lyle’s golden syrup? Made some other way? Made with some maple syrup? Don’t know. It’s the Karo syrup variety that is too sweet – but I still eat it if it has more pecans than that Karo syrup stuff.
My favorite pie is chocolate silk.
I love blueberry pie.
Love a cherry pie but in terms of peanut butter desserts they are endless- a quick peanut butter cake with a side of brownies to put together very similar to Reese peanut butter cup. Or peanut butter and jelly pie – yum so many options and choices to make!
This looks delicious! Derby Pie is my favorite—a delicious blend of chocolate pecans and bourbon.
My favorite pie is peanut butter pie with chocolate ganache…delicious!
My favorite pie is a firm–not runny–blueberry pie with lightly sugared top crust.
My favorite pie is Apple with a crumb top. Delicious!
I love all pie! My favorites would have to be pecan or savory hand pies, though.
My favorite pie is salted caramel apple, with peach pie coming a close second.
This summer was my introduction to pie making. It took me almost 50 years of baking to overcome my fear of crusts! 🙂 My new favorite pie is homemade Cherry Pie.
Delicious! My favorite pies are those my grandmothers made. I love cherry but any pie they made was delicious! I keep trying to replicate it but it is never quite the same. I think their own love is missing….. I enjoy baking and eating! One of my children’s favorite treats are buckeyes. Peanut butter is always a crowd pleaser!
I keep thinking, I have so many favorites. Decorated sugar cookies, I love them with frosting!
My mouth is watering….. can’t wat to start holiday baking!
I love anything with peanuts (both savory and sweets) but never had peanut butter pie before. So far, my favorite pie is a pumpkin pie 🙂
My absolute FAVORITE pie is a homemade peach pie with home made crust from Great Grama, and Fresh Red Haven Peaches we’ve just picked (up in Michigan) & canned!!!! Needs no ice cream or anything else. Just peachy goodness & heavenly flakey crust through and through!
My favorite peanut butter recipe is LifeLoveandSugar.com’s Peanut Butter Chocolate Layer cake. It is decadent, but just a small slice quenches my Reese’s craving every time. https://www.lifeloveandsugar.com/peanut-butter-chocolate-layer-cake/
I also have very find memories of my mom’s homemade cherry pie. She always used tart cherrie that we often picked and pitted ourselves. If we missed a pit and it ended up in the pie, the person who “got it” got an extra sliver of pie.
I am an apple pie sans cinnamon lover!
Hi Zoe and Elizabeth! I love pie…one of my absolute new FAVES is a Blue Ribbon Winner: Peanut Butter Chiffon Pie With Peanut Butter Caramel And Sour Cream Whipped Cream Topping! I so want to try Elizabeth’s Peanut Butter Meringue Pie, that sounds so delicious!
I LOVE Banana Cream Pie with a peanut butter cookie crust! Topped with meringue and chocolate shavings.
My favorite pie is Betty’s Pies blueberry pie recipe using blueberries from our patch
My favorite pie is apple pie with caramel. I can’t get enough of homemade buckeyes
My favorite pie dutch apple pie!
My favorite pie is blueberry. Or lemon meringue. Or Derby Pie. Or apple with a crumb topping. And I adore anything with peanut butter!
I make a Black Forest pie that my family loves!
That’ s a tough question – but coconut cream or banana cream would be my favs.
My favorite pie is a sour cherry pie. The best!
My favorite pie of all time is a tie between lemon meringue and three berry pie, made with blackberries, raspberries & blueberries. Love your show and can’t wait for new episodes! Have you given any thought to include an episode on gluten free desserts? I bake for friends with celiacs.
My favorite peanut butter dessert recipe is Peanut Butter High Hat Cupcakes.
They’re our family’s favorite and most requested by friends for their special
gatherings.
Favorite PB sweet is the classic peanut butter cookie made with crunchy style on – crisp edges dunked in a glass of ice cold milk – YUM!
I’ve had a growing affinity for coffee cream pie in the last few years. I serve it with brunch and it’s always a hit!
Love anything peanut butter but my favorite pie is old fashion buttermilk pie
I love pie and to name a favorite would be really hard but since you asked it would have to be Coconut Cream. Thank you for the giveway!
French silk pie !
Christmas Tree Pie is my favorite. Cherries pecan s and whipped cream. My mom made it every Christmas Holiday. I also love peanut butter fudge and peanut soup from the taverns in Williamsburg Virginia
Peanut Buster Parfait (but homemade).
Key Lime pie is my favorite. I prefer it with a graham cracker crust, but I’ve had it at Krewe in St Joe’s with a traditional pie crust and that’s good too. I think a chocolate Graham or salted pretzel crust would be a good test. I also love it piled with fresh strawberries when the season allows.
I love a blueberry pie mid summer.
Key lime pie!
Dutch apple pie!
My favorite pie depends on what’s in season and the time of year – Rhubarb in the spring, Peach in August, Apple in the Fall, Cranberry Lime after a big Thanksgiving meal. But no matter what, it’s always a la mode!!!
Fresh peach pie–not baked. Baked crust, smear of cream cheese to seal and then lots of fresh peaches held together by a cooked peach sauce. So delicious!
My favorite pie to bake is Pecan Pie simply put because it’s my husband’s favorite. Nothing better than baking for those you love!
My very favorite pie is sugar cream pie ( state pie of Indiana).
I honestly have never met a piece of pie that I did not love. I love to make pie, serve pie, and eat pie.
My favorite pie is butterscotch with a meringue topping. My grandmother taught me to make it and now I make them for all holiday gatherings.
Peach pie please
Salted Carmel Apple Pie is always my favorite!
Cherry pie!!
I love a good ol’ Dutch Apple Pie!
I’m a chocoholic, so a chocolate pie is my favorite.
Apple pie – but can’t wait to make Elizabeth’s Peanut Butter masterpiece!!
Apple pie – but can’t wait to make Elizabeth’s Peanut Butter masterpiece!!
My favorite pie is a pi phi…my college sorority sisters from SDSU. ❤️ but when it’s time to bake a pie I always go for a good old fashion APPLE PIE a la mode. It’s my husband’s favorite too. Ya never know…chances are this Peanut Butter pie with meringue may become our new favorite . Please pick me
Asking me to pick a favorite pie is like asking me to tell which of our cats is my favorite. 😉 I don’t think there is a pie I have meant that I haven’t liked: pumpkin, pecan, chocolate, lemon meringue, key lime, coconut cream, blueberry, rhubarb, cherry, peach the list goes on … As for a peanut butter dessert, I do love me some good ole buckeyes. But a Peanut Butter Crunch cookie from Gideon’s Bakehouse might be a close 2nd.
Peanut Butter Mousse Cake.
Thin chocolate wafer cookies layered in peanut butter mousse and topped with dark chocolate curls.
Let me just say YUM!!
My favorite pie is Shoo Fly Pie! I discovered it while on a trip to Lancaster, Pennsylvania, 1972.
And, fast forward 40 years, I had a daughter who went to college about an hour from my obsession…nothing better; my favorite pie with my favorite person
I love Ina Garten’s Chocolate Cupcakes with Peanut Butter Frosting!!! The frosting is beyond heavenly! It barely makes it on the cupcakes! I make vanilla cupcakes too as a vehicle for the frosting!
My favorite peanut butter recipe is the Peanut Butter Blossom Cookies made at Christmas, with the Hershey kiss pressed into the center, then sprinkled with either red or green sugar. They are obviously magical because Santa has never failed to leave gifts when these delightful treats are left for him!
My all time favorite pie is French Silk pie.
Hi! Lemon Meringue Pie is my favorite, with Key Lime in a close second! Peanut Butter recipe would have to be a Peanut Butter/Chocolate Chunk cookie recipe!
Key Lime!
My very favorite pie is a peanut butter pie made like a pecan pie with peanut butter and peanuts replacing pecans. Fabulous!
Peanut Butter Blondies!
This pie looks delicious!
Would love the cookbook!!
My favorite pie is probably blueberry, while I have rarely met a homemade pie I didn’t like! Meringue pies are especially favorites of my family and I tend to make pies fairly often! I can’t wait to try the recipes in this book – they look delicious!
Apple is a family choice for most gatherings. MY favorite is Raisin Sour Cream pie (also my Mom’s favorite).
My favorite peanut butter dessert is from a restaurant I used to work at, A Bowl of Good, named on the menu as “Peanut butter Paradise Bars”. Thick brownie crust, peanut butter filling and chocolate ganache topping! I’ve tired making them at home, but I also get one whenever I’m back visiting A Bowl of Good!
My favorite pie is Cherry. I have great memories of using fresh picked cherries in Michigan and my friend making her grandmother’s pie crust recipe.
My favorite pie is apple but I do love all things peanut butter. You can’t beat simple peanut butter balls!
My absolute favorite pie is a peanut butter pie
Made like a pecan pie but with peanut butter and peanuts. OMG it’s so good!
Dutch apple or French silk…..and basically anything chocolate/PB is good with me!
Fav peanut butter dessert is a chocolate kahlua peanut butter cake. It’s chocolate cake with kahlua soak, and a peanut butter frosting. So delicious. Favorite pie would have to be coconut creme pie.
Peanut butter cookies are my favourite. Simple tastes!
I love key lime pie and peanut butter honey pie
My favorite pie comes from a shop here in Texas. It is a chocolate silk pie in a pretzel crust. It’s called “The Smooth Operator”!
My favorite pie is mincemeat pie that is made with my own mincemeat…green tomatoes, raisins and spices combine to make a delicious base for this custard pie! I spent years perfecting the crust for the lattice top! This pie is part of my family’s traditional Thanksgiving feast!
Peanut butter cream cheese pie.
My favorite pie is chocolate peanut butter mousse pie topped with Chambord soaked raspberries.
My favorite pie is any type of fruit galette–not too sweet and full of seasonal fruits. I also adore fruit crisps with extra oat crumb topping. My secret delight using peanut butter is to spread it on apple slices with a drizzle of honey. I “discovered” that in college when I needed a sweet and cheap treat!
I adore good old fashioned peanut butter cookies with the fork cross-cross on top! Yummy! My fav pie is peach!
My favorite pie is a Lemon Meringue that is ultra tart with sweet meringue.
My favorite peanut butter recipe is Bobby Flay’s Coffee Chunky Monkey Smoothie, although I do really love your chocolate peanut butter cake too!
Banana cream pie with graham cracker crust!
My favorite is an apple pie with lots of crumb topping served with vanilla bean ice cream.
I love peanut butter pie, I make one with an Oreo crust, and then drizzle chocolate syrup & caramel on the top
My favorite pie is banana cream pie! I do love anything peanut butter though.
My favorite pie is key lime. Favorite PB dessert would be any kind of peanut butter and chocolate combination.
My dearly departed Mother’s lemon meringue pie is my fav! Costco organic peanut butter by the spoonful is my go to.
My favorite pie is Christmas Tree pie made with cherries, pecans and whipped cream. My mom always made it during the holidays. I also love peanut butter fudge!
My grandmothers lemon meringue pie.
My favorite pie is coconut cream pie and apple crumble pie.
My favorite pie is apple!!
I have a fun way that I love to make it and it’s so easy! It’s apple pie bars with a shortbread crust and a crumble topping. I’m all about the CRUMBLE!!
I absolutely love the fall! It’s my favorite season for decorating and baking my favorite desserts.
Happy baking ya’ll!!
Picking a favorite pie is tough! I do love a good pecan pie! But I think this peanut butter meringue pie would be right up my alley!
Pies! So many favorites! Pecan, blueberry, apple, lemon. I could go on forever.
My favorite is pecan pie
Peach pie made with Texas Hill Country peaches with a streusel topping.
Peanut butte cookies.
Simple peanut butter cookies! rolled in right for an extra crunch. 🙂
Hi Zoe!
My favorite pie of all time is black-bottom pie!
Pecan Pie, but my husbands is peanut butter pie!
Will try this one!
Apple crumb pie, forever and ever!
My favorite peanut butter recipe is Chocolate Peanut-Butter-Cup Cookies, The recipe came from Wally Amos of Famous Amos fame. It’s always a hit with adults and children.
My mom’s strawberry rhubarb pie is my fav!
I love a fruit pie of any kind, but strawberry rhubarb is at the top of the list. Yum!
Warm apple pie! Peanut butter pie! Yum to both. Still not great a crust but the is pretty tasty!
My favorite peanut butter dessert is peanut butter ice cream! But peanut butter fudge, cookies, and pie are all in the running 🙂
My favorite pie is butterscotch meringue pie.
I love ALL pies but probably a lemon or berry pie would be my favorite. The peanut butter meringue pie looks delicious so I will have to try that for sure!!
Strawberry pie or Bayou Goo pie from a local bakery!
Love Ranch to Table show- never miss an episode, would love to win this cookbook as have yet to get it – on a strict budget right now- thanks
Favorite peanut butter dessert is peanut cupcakes with peanut butter frosting.
Pie and I are old friends, but I think my bestie is French Silk Pie. She is there for all the drama and is often in my thoughts.
I love pie, any and all pie.
I love any pie too, but I was born on Thanksgiving day, and as it turns out my birthday cake was actually pumpkin pie nearly every year. And I love a good pumpkin pie especially if it’s served with my aunt Joany’s world famous hard sauce.
My favorite peanut butter recipe is my Grandmother’s peanut butter cookies. They are by far the tastiest I have ever had. They have very simple ingredients yet I have not found any other recipe taste as good as hers.
Chocolate cream pie!
Hi Zoe, my all-time favorite pie is sour cream raisin. It’s an old family, favorite and I always have to make it for my mom and my husband on their birthdays. And because of your influence, I have become a torch fan as well browning the beautiful Swiss meringue that sits piled on top of this rich clove, infused sour cream pie. Thanks, Julie.
My favorite pie is lemon meringue. The flavor is so bright and cheerful. I also love peanut butter cookies!
My favourite pie is an upside down pecan apple pie where the top of the pie (when inverted) is the pie crust topped with pecans and brown sugar. Serve warm with a scoop of vanilla ice cream or dollop of homemade whipped cream. Favourite peanut butter recipe is a chewy peanut butter chocolate chip cookie made with a mix of milk and semi sweet chocolate chips.
Fresh strawberry pie is my favorite!
My family is a chocolate peanut butteraholic! I love her family’s rich history on the farm. Ranch to table is like a beautiful trip into the Wild West.
Fav pie- banana butterscotch.
Fav pb- oatmeal pb cookies
My favorite pie is apple pie, love how the warm spices smell up the home. I just love the basic and classic peanut butter cookies and to spike it up a bit.. I love to add chocolate chunks!
My favorite pie is my grandma’s apple pie with cheese!
My favorite is banana cream pie!
Hmm. Chocolate pie, fruit pie, vegetable savory pie..clearly, I like pie!
Favorite pie is Magnolia Table Lemon Pie! Easy to make and oh so yummy
So many pies to choose from as well as peanutbutter deserts. My favorite pie is probably pumpkin and my favorite peanutbutter desert is just a spoonful of peanutbutter, my siblings and I called it a “peanutbutter lollipop”.
Before packing of items became so difficult to open, we would help our parents carry in the Saturday weekly groceries and rummage through the bags to find the peanutbutter, if you found it first, you would open it and take a finger full, especially the swirl of peanutbutter. Inevitably, one of the siblings would swoop in the steal the swirl from you as you where hold jar in one hand and lid in the other. Sounds silly, but it was fun.
My favorite pie is peach, I actually use a recipe from Zoe, best peach pie I ever had. Peanut butter dessert is hard, love them all, but Salted Peanut Butter cookies from Smitten Kitchen are divine!
I ❤️ anything with peanut butter but my fav would be a peanut butter pie with chocolate ganache.. YUM!
Lemon meringue all the way!
I love peanut butter blossoms and the peanut putter brittle I make
Freshly harvested ,from the garden ,rhubarb pie with a very flakey crust. Perfect.
I can’t say I have a clear favorite in the pie category because I have a favorite for different times of the year. If I had to pick one it would be a coconut custard pie.
Favorite pie: toss up between blueberry and chocolate cream. Favorite peanut butter dessert: peanut butter chocolate chip cookies. What can I say – I’m basic 🙂
So hard to choose a favorite pie, but black raspberry would probably take first over Coconut Cream and Sour Cherry. Favorite peanut butter dessert would be a peanut butter mousse with chocolate.
Salted honey pie is my favorite, it’s so yummy
German chocolate pie is my favorite! ❤️
I love my homemade peanut butter pie with a layer of dark chocolate mousse on the top.
My favorite fall pie is a spiced pear pie. I just made one yesterday.
Lemon Meringue pie! My grandmother made it for us for every special occasion. I’ve never been able to accurately re-create the recipe. Mustards Grill in Napa Valley, California has a fabulous lemon meringue pie. I seek it out every time I go to Northern California.
My favorite Peanut Butter dessert is a deep, dark chocolate cake with homemade peanut butter icing — a perfect combination. Even better, my hubby doesn’t like PB, so I have it ALL TO MYSELF!
I do like a really good peanut butter pie, or pecan or lemon meringue. Geez it’s hard to pick as I like pie and more importantly desserts. I have thought I would like to open a dessert restaurant with a 4 course dessert menu. Eat dessert first and then you won’t fill up on the meal.
My favorite pie is Lemon Meringue Pie. It brings back many memories of my grandfather who taught me a lot about baking! (I love peanut butter too!)
I love a delicious banana cream pie!
My favorite pie is a fresh strawberry pie and unfortunately I’m allergic to peanuts in large doses so a rare handful of Reese’s Pieces or a no-bake cookie is the totality of my peanut consumption.
Favorite pie…salted caramel honeycrisp crunch apple pie. Favorite PB recipe – chocolate PB macaron. Tons of others too, but always this apple pie
My favorite pie is lemon meringue. The flavor is so bright and cheerful. I also love peanut butter cookies!
My favorite pie is french silk. It’s so rich and creamy and the chocolate shavings on top make it even better!
My favorite pie is butter pecan pie Southern butter pecan pie at that, living in Wisconsin now coming from North Carolina, I always make this pie almost every weekend it stairs up so many memories from my childhood my grandmother taught me how to make pecan pie when I was 11 years old and since then I have loved to bake.
My favorite pie is pecan cream , and I love peanut butter cookies❤️
Hii, my favorite pie is the classic apple pie with some vanilla ice cream on top
My favorite pie is s custard based banana cream pie. Favorite peanut butter recipe is peanut butter cookies. I can still remember my mom making them and the wonderful smells!
Ohhh! I’ve never heard of a pecan cream pie and it sounds delicious!
Oh wow, I love both of your shows and all your amazing recipes!
And I have to also tell you, Zoe, how much I love your hair! Absolutely gorgeous 🙂 I think that every show, so I figured I’d just mention it here 🙂
I’m pretty simple… a super gooey & chewy brownie… or good chocolate chip cookies, with the crispy/chewy edges amd a soft center…… oh boy I definitely need to make those again soon… well, once its cooled down more 😉
My favorite peanut butter dessert is a jar of peanut butter. I can and do eat it every way, even on grilled hamburgers.
Homemade Nutter Butter cookies from Bravetart cookbook!
I’ve never had peanut butter pie. ..sounds really good…My favorite pie is Apple crisp …. When apples are in season ..with ice cream on the side…
Ice cream pumpkin pie
My favorite pie is chocolate cream pie. My husband likes a version if my cream pie using a layer of peanutbutter and layer of bananas lol. He requests it for his birthday every year.
Pumpkin pie all the way!!
Can’t beat Sarah Kiefer’s peanut butter cookies in a pinch!
My favorite pie is coconut cream with whipped cream and toasted coconut on top. I would love to try this peanut butter pie.
It’s so hard to choose my favorite pie, but I’m going to say key lime—although cherry comes in a close second!
Apple pie is my favorite but I love ANYTHING peanut butter!
My grandfather grew rhubarb in his garden and cooked it on the stove for ice cream or made a pie. I love straight rhubarb pie…. reminds me of him and I’m a kid again!
Rhubarb….Yes!!! And no strawberries please. My Mother and her family always added some grated orange rind.
My favorite pie is an old fashion apple pie with no frills
Key lime pie… real key lime pie
My favorite pie is raspberry pie. I love the sweet-tart flavors off it.
Hi
My favorite pie is a tart cherry pie and homemade pumpkin pie with vanilla bean ice cream.
Cherry pie.
I love a mile high apple pie drizzled with caramel and served a la mode! It’s just so incredibly comforting ❤️
My favorite pie is a fall classic, Apple pie. We use Granny Smith apples. I love the crumble top. It’s my favorite for Thanksgiving.
Favorite pie is cherry with a good vanilla ice cream. I make a pretty good peanut butter sheet cake that I like a well.
My favorite is dark chocolate pie with a whipped topping and chocolate curls.
I love peach pie,
But I also love blueberry, pumpkin, pecan and mincemeat
I guess I just love pies!
Cherry pie…or chocolate cream… or pumpkin, this is a tough question!
My father owned a cafe in a small town and was well known for his delicious, memorable homemade pies. My favorite was his apple pie, warm with vanilla ice cream. His mastered talent of creating the perfect flakey crust, choosing the most flavorful apples and the right amounts of the sugar, cinnamon and nutmeg.
My favorite fall pie is Concord Grape pie, with a hot cup of strong Irish Tea
Fresh peach blueberry pie!
Hi my favorite peanut butter dessert are buckeye balls. They are peanut butter with chocolate delights!
I love peanut butter bars.
My heart belongs to sour cherry pie! I spent my youth camping with family the entire summer in the cherry capital of the world, Traverse City, MI. We often picked cherries to make pies, cobblers and jam. These great memories come rolling back with every bite of a homemade cherry pie. ❤️❣️
Peach pie!
I love all fruit pies but my grandmother’s apple pie still transports me back in time. I’m the only person in our tiny family who learned to make it. It tastes like love.
Sorry .. I love all pie … but if I had to have a favorite it has to be Rhubarb Custard.. no has made that pie as well as my mother in law.. every birthday and yes I ate the whole thing by myself!
My favorite peanut butter dessert is the peanut butter blossom cookie. We make them every Christmas. Abd since they are gluten free, my daughter can enjoy them as well!
Peanut butter fudge or a Reeses peanut butter cup!
My favorite pie would be pecan pie!
My favorite pie is chocolate peanut butter! I would love to win a copy of this cookbook!
Huckleberry is the best
I love the combination of raspberries and fresh peaches in pies, tarts, or just in a bowl topped with vanilla ice cream!
My father grew up on a cattle ranch in Northern New Mexico and I loved hearing his stories and I still have the old registered cattle brand certificates. My favorite pie is sweet potato pie
Gooseberry and elderflower pie
My favorite pie is apple pie made with lots of cinnamon!
Lemon pie, no meringue
My favorite pie are strawberry rhubarb or Marion berries pie. Yum!!
Hello Zoe and Elizabeth! I love Angel Pie with a chocolate meringue crust. Thanks for your contest!
My favorite pie is pecan. My southern granddaddy loved his pecan pie and coconut cream pie and I loved him!❤️
My favorite pie is pumpkin! My mother in law and I just love watching both of your shows on Magnolia!
My favorite pie to make is peach pie with a special crust when peach season hits! I love adding a bit of cardamom as I just love the flavor!
My favorite pie is apple pie or pecan pie… hard to choose!
My favorite pie is pumpkin!
My favorite pie is a lattice topped peach pie with vanilla ice cream.
I have recently been watching Ms. Poetts show & find it simply intriguing. I love it!
Favorite PNB dessert is PNB Oatmeal Bars with homemade PNB frosting. I have been making these since our kids were little. They are now in their 30’s. A favorite in our household & circle of family & friends.
My favorite pie is lemon meringue, but this peanut butter meringue looks amazing.
My favorite pie is any one my 95 year old mother makes. She has been our “pie lady” all our lives and still makes them for us. My daughter always asks for a pie from Grandma when she comes to visit. and Grandma always comes through.
Hello!
What a gorgeous book! And that pie looks amazing. It’s hard to choose just one favorite pie, but today it would be lemon meringue.
Pecan pie is May favorite! I just heard an interview with Elizabeth on the Cherry Bomb pod. Her family ranch sounds amazing. They were bio diverse long before it was a “thing”!
Lemon meringue pie is a favorite from childhood.
I love coconut cream pie
I love pie of all kinds but my all time favorite is Lemon Meringue.
Love both these shows
Love maine blueberry pie.
Peanut butter pie.
Peanut butter and jelly bars.
Thanks so much
Cherry pie
I love all pies! Peach or berry crumble pie
My favorite pie is pecan
Rhubarb pie, peanut butter rice krispie bars
Raspberry apple pie
My favorite has always been and will be cherry with pecan a close second! This PB pie looks delicious.
I love a Chai Apple Pie!
I love apple pies and peanut butter blossoms.