Peanut Butter Meringue Pie from The Ranch Table

840 comments
Peanut Butter Pie in a ceramic pie plate on a marble countertop

I met Elizabeth Poett in Waco, TX after we both started filming our shows for The Magnolia Network. Elizabeth is the rare combination of movie star glamour and a down-to-earth rancher. Those things seem an impossible mix and yet, Elizabeth pulls it off with rugged elegance. She has a passion for her traditions, her land, and her family, which makes her so relatable.

[GIVEAWAY! Scroll to the bottom to find out how you can win a copy of Elizabeth Poett’s new cookbook!]

Her new cookbook tells the story of her picture book ranch, filled with cattle, honey bees, lavender fields, and views one could never get tired of. Most importantly it is where her family has lived for seven generations.

I am decidedly a city dweller but I am so captivated and curious about her bucolic world. If you’ve seen her show, Ranch to Table, you’ve probably felt the same pull to ranch life. You can get her recipes and stories in her new book, The Ranch Table, which includes this family-favorite peanut butter meringue pie. Be sure to check out Elizabeth’s show! Season 4 just launched on Magnolia Network.

Peanut Butter Pie in a ceramic pie plate on a marble countertop

GIVEAWAY! Want to win a copy of this gorgeous cookbook? Leave a comment and tell me your favorite pie or your favorite peanut butter dessert recipe! USA addresses only. Must be 18 years of age or older to enter. Giveaway closes Friday, Oct. 13, 2023 at 5 p.m. CST. One winner will be contacted via email. If we do not hear back from the winner within 48 hours, we will select and notify a new winner.

840 Comments

  1. Banana cream pie is my fave ♥️

  2. Cindy Stewart

    Bourbon pecan pie! I make it every thanksgiving and it gets devoured in minutes.

  3. Sue Smith Taylor

    My favorite pie is pumpkin with lots of spice and
    Creamy whipped cream!!!

  4. Favorite Pie…Green Chile Apple

  5. Raisin pie-my aunt’s.

  6. Terry Mcglennon

    Cherry crumb pie!

  7. Connie Leonard

    Butterfinger pie! Just loads of scrumptious unhealthy calories!

  8. My favorite pie is my Grandmother’s recipe for straight up Rhubarb Pie! It’s also my husband’s favorite. He once ate an entire rhubarb pie with his fingers driving from IL to Michigan!

  9. I’m not a pie person but I love a French Silk Pie. I could eat the whole thing!!

  10. Forever: sour cream apple pie. The mix of tangy apples, a great crust, sour cream and a buttery crunchy topping are out of this world. YUM.

  11. Have to put in my vote for Marionberry Pie. Such a unique sweet/tart flavor that reminds me of growing up in the Pacific Northwest.

    As for a peanut butter dessert, I recommend Smitten Kitchen’s Chocolate Peanut Butter layer cake. I made it for one birthday party and it now has a devoted fanbase spanning two counties.

  12. My favorite pie is rhubarb custard.pie.

  13. Pecan Pie…for sure!

  14. Pamela Bradley

    Homemade apple pie with glaze

  15. Jean Catanzaro

    Hello Zoe and Elizabeth,
    I love lemon meringue pie when I was young girl I didn’t like the Meringue part of the pie and my Grandmom would make me a pie without the meringue. Now I love the meringue on the pie. I watch your show and Elizabeth’s show and record them so I can watch with my 7 year old granddaughter who loves watching both shows.

  16. Tammy Stewart

    I love a good mud pie. The peanut butter meringue pie looks delicious. I can’t wait to make this one.

  17. Cynthi Hrabe

    My favorite pies are pumpkin and French silk. And for peanut butter dessert, I have to go with Reese’s peanut butter cheesecake. Thanks!!

  18. Banana Cream Pie!!!

  19. Christie Mildon

    Peanut butter cream pie with a pretzel crust. Sweet and salty!

  20. Jeffry Morgan

    My Favorite Pie Is a Lemon Pie with sour cream Topping and my Second is A Tart Cherry Pie. Oh Well, I Love all Desserts. LOL

  21. Donne Huston

    Zoe, my favorite pie would be a Bavarian Harvest Berry Pie with a Crumble topping. I serve it warm with a scoop of good vanilla ice cream or a luscious dollop of fresh whipped cream. The first time I tasted this pie was from a small farm bakery in Pennsylvania. I make one every fall to celebrate the changing of the season.

  22. One of my favorite pies was my moms Rhubarb pie with a crumble topping!

  23. My kid’s favorite is a Nutella pie. Would love to try and make the peanut butter pie and some other pies ❤️

  24. Rainna Baker

    Hi Zoe and Elizabeth
    For me it’s Apple pie. It can be a regular apple pie, Dutch, caramel you name it I will eat it. Especially warm with vanilla ice cream.

  25. I love no bake chocolate oatmeal cookies. I use chunky peanut butter for some crunch!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*