Peanut Butter Meringue Pie from The Ranch Table

840 comments
Peanut Butter Pie in a ceramic pie plate on a marble countertop

I met Elizabeth Poett in Waco, TX after we both started filming our shows for The Magnolia Network. Elizabeth is the rare combination of movie star glamour and a down-to-earth rancher. Those things seem an impossible mix and yet, Elizabeth pulls it off with rugged elegance. She has a passion for her traditions, her land, and her family, which makes her so relatable.

[GIVEAWAY! Scroll to the bottom to find out how you can win a copy of Elizabeth Poett’s new cookbook!]

Her new cookbook tells the story of her picture book ranch, filled with cattle, honey bees, lavender fields, and views one could never get tired of. Most importantly it is where her family has lived for seven generations.

I am decidedly a city dweller but I am so captivated and curious about her bucolic world. If you’ve seen her show, Ranch to Table, you’ve probably felt the same pull to ranch life. You can get her recipes and stories in her new book, The Ranch Table, which includes this family-favorite peanut butter meringue pie. Be sure to check out Elizabeth’s show! Season 4 just launched on Magnolia Network.

Peanut Butter Pie in a ceramic pie plate on a marble countertop

GIVEAWAY! Want to win a copy of this gorgeous cookbook? Leave a comment and tell me your favorite pie or your favorite peanut butter dessert recipe! USA addresses only. Must be 18 years of age or older to enter. Giveaway closes Friday, Oct. 13, 2023 at 5 p.m. CST. One winner will be contacted via email. If we do not hear back from the winner within 48 hours, we will select and notify a new winner.

840 Comments

  1. Stephen Elliott

    The Sweet Potato Pecan Pie from K-Paul’s in New Orleans (which sadly closed) was the best–thankfully the recipe is in Paul Prudhomme’s Louisiana Kitchen Cookbook.

  2. Brenda Scherer

    Looks like a great book! My favorite pie is Key Lime

  3. Tiffanie Lin

    Apple pumpkin pie with a crumb topping!!

  4. Lori Boothman

    It’s a toss up…coconut cream pie or rhubarb pie. I love either one!

  5. Amy McCullagh

    I love good pies! Homemade and scumptious – like key lime, lemon meringue, rhubarb, apple. But I have a special love of Peanut Butter Pie. I had never had one until I went to college at the University of Alabama in Tuscaloosa. A small diner near campus made the most delicious peanut butter pie, with a high, fluffy meringue. It is a food memory that I have never been able to replicate. The restaurant no longer exits, and I can’t recall the name, but that peanut butter pie is legendary in my mind. It was no overly sweet, but creamy, and the meringue topped it like a crown.

  6. It’s a toss up…coconut cream pie or rhubarb pie. I love either one!

  7. Tami Michael

    Peach pie is my favorite ❤️

  8. Matthew Morales

    Cherry Pie is my #1. As a kid I always got one for my birthday instead of a cake. . This Peanut Butter recipe looks amazing, can’t wait to try it!

  9. Hello Zoe and Elizabeth,
    I love watching both of your shows. Zoe I Can’t wait to see Season 4. I hope it airs soon. My favorite pie is a rhubarb and raspberry pie.

  10. I love peanut butter pie! My husband and I love Elizabeth’s show and yours as well Zoe! We would love a copy of her cookbook!

  11. My favorite pie is a Marionberry pie. Peanut butter with dark chocolate is a winner in anything! I love both your shows!

  12. My mom would make a peanut butter pie that was similar to this recipe, and everyone loved it! ❤️She was even featured in the local newspaper with her peanut butter pie. Now I make it for my grandkids..

  13. My favorite is Peanut Butter Pie with a bit of chocolate on top !!!

  14. Diane DeCurtis

    My most favorite pie is a chocolate pudding pie with homemade whipped cream.

  15. Sandy Weihing

    I love a pecan- pumpkin pie this time of year!!

  16. Connie Wiedemann

    This pie looks amazing and I love chocolate and apple pies, also.

  17. Stephanie Zwirn

    My favorite pie is Apple with cheddar cheese. Win or loss I will be getting the cookbook, I love peanut butter and will be baking this soon.

  18. Michelle Vandergrift

    Peanut butter cookies are my favorite!

  19. Kirstie Helsene

    Dutch apple pie–best of both apple dessert worlds: pie crust and oat-y crumble! Also love my great-aunt’s cranberry-pecan pie.

  20. Pumpkin cream cheese pie is one of my top favorites. Pie is my favorite treat!!

  21. Patricia Sferrazza

    This peanut butter pie looks amazing!!! My favorite pie is a toss up between a nice warm s’mores pie or a pumpkin pie with fresh cream!

  22. Pamela Walton

    I lov watching Magnolia Network!!! Ranch to table makes rustic elegant delicious food!!!!!! I get excited to try and make her recipes. (My husband also enjoys the recipes from the show I make .)
    My favorite pie is her classic lemon meringue. But I also love her Peach Buckle!!!

  23. Stephanie Sajjadieh

    Peanut butter is my favorite food, so it would be worth getting the book for the peanut butter pie recipe alone!

  24. My favorite pie is Pumpkin! My favorite peanut butter recipe is for Buckeyes!

  25. Dana Beauvais

    Hello
    My favorite peanut butter recipe is my Nanny’s peanut butter fudge. I’ve tried to replicate it with her recipe, even, but it’s never as good. My favorite pie comes with the change of the seasons. Spring brings cherry pie; summer lemon and lime and peach pies; fall apple, pecan; winter brings hearty pies like chocolate and peanut butter!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*